The great man? Why were you asking Sachin Tendulkar about time keeping?

I stand by my comment. Mr Leahy gave a penalty last season in a Dewsbury game I watched in the same circumstance.

Anyway, I still think it went over.

Oh come on. That just proves it must be wrong.

Surely the balls dead when picked up by the second Batley player?

Good point.......

Or play to the whistle ?

True, that's an iffy rule.

Thought the first offside was accidental, anyway.

Still offside, accidental or not.

But not a penalty.

Right, anyway, some blokes on the Batley forum are saying there was no hooter. Definitely. So I apologise. I must've imagined it.

Was definitely more of an SBD than a "Bronx cheer" hooter

I must admit it was hardly loud, I did just about hear it though.

I heard it fine. Quite loud too.

It was on your side of the ground though.

Very loud from where I was.

After just watching the highlights on EAGLES TV

I can confirm the horn was very loud

Looking at it on eagles tv. It was fair to give play on. Point accepted.

Drop-goal not on though..

There kick at the end looked very close

No, went out of shot, didn't it ?

I thought it was over but Tubbs said Paul Handforth said he thought it missed.

Hardly conclusive but it's just another iffy decision.

Incidentally, has anyone else noticed that the number of times the touch judges can't agree on a kick is increasing? It's quite common now whereas it used to be virtually unknown.

Yes ive noticed. Three this season, I'd never seen it before this year.