I'm afraid so - all the red stuff is eaten by Ryan MacDonald

haven 32-4 fev mcnally 20, not HT yet i think will be top points scorer in nl1 if not in all leagues this year, got to get to the bookies, hope he can steer clear of injuries, and the headhunters, think he will be a walk in for the Giants next year

32 point haul, really impressive

What a star, ripped us apart

ooh sounds a great prospect - cant wait to see him in the C&G !!

Yes no promotion will help the NL/Championship clubs to bring through youngsters to build teams rather than spend money on ex SL/Queensland cup players trying to win the GF and a SL spot

Or not

Well said Starbug. Would like to see ten young English (British) players brought through than an Aussie on a retirement pay-day ?

Yes I would , but i'd also like the club that brings them through be in a position to offer those young British players a good future at that club , unfortunatley that is not the case

My club Leigh is currently playing a fully british team and has done so for several weeks including 7/8 who have come through Leigh's junior ranks , in fact Leigh are the last club to win a major trophy with an all British team

I dont know what the deal between Whitehaven and Huddersfield is with regards McNally but I'll guess Haven wont be jumping through hoops about it

If you don't know why bother with childish negative guessing?

If you think McNally will reach his full potential training pt in a club with limited resources and playing in the Championship for several more years you are wrong.

is Mc nally injured

Missed last week with thigh strain, came off bench yesterday. Hasn't looked interested in last few weeks

be good to see him make s/l.

But if he has to bulk up to do so, won't he become slower and therefore less deadly in attack?

He's a class act and can make it IMO!

Bulking up doesn't neccesairily make you slow! Look at the size of sprinters etc! The only thing it may effect is agility etc! Plus look at Burrow not huge but strong, am sure McNally is working hard on that area!

As above, have always rated the lad...

But tonight was an aboslute whingeback, every call was crying and every Haven knock on as well.

He offered nout himself an all like!

To be fair he was playing behind a beaten pack. We've seen ourselves that our halfbacks cant play their usual game when our pack are on the backfoot for most of the game.

may have played well against some lower teas but when cam to the crunch against a main team he was missing in action, onlky thing he did was set himself up nicely for Doran to crunch him and then play dead for a while

Kevin Brown when he started off in the Wigan 1st team anyone? His potential was spotted and now he's a great player for Huddersfield.

I thought some of you might be interested in this item on Mc Nally. has put 2 stone on since joining the Giants. www.examiner.co.uk/huddersfield- ... -25611912/

I thought some of you might be interested in this item on Mc Nally. has put 2 stone on since joining the Giants. www.examiner.co.uk/huddersfield- ... -25611912/

Was actually thinking about McNally and Hudds this week... is he staying their this year or back to 'Haven even that article not very clear. With Hudds IMO still laking two out and out halfs (even talk of Robinson moving to 9) would of thought it'd be a good chance to throw McNally in from the off and see how he goes!

To be honest i have absolutely no idea what the Giants are going to be playing this year. We might see Mc Nally if we get a couple of injuries . the jury still seems out on him. We need to see more skill and running the attacking plays from him rather than backing up and scoring tries.

I am sure he will come on in leaps and bounds soon though. Sean lunt is looking like a potential international hooker after one season with the Giants.

he's cack

Very constructive. Welcome to the party.

He'll be proping soon.

news.bbc.co.uk/sport1/hi/rugby_l ... 586868.stm Back on loan with you guys.

news.bbc.co.uk/sport1/hi/rugby_l ... 586868.stm Back on loan with you guys.