I have been watching Rovers for over 50 yrs and some of the present bunch have been pinching money

These Player In my opinion should be let go or have gone or should go

Players out or gone or should be let go

Shannon McDonnel - we gave him a go when no one wanted him on Oz he pays us back by wanting more money let Hull Fc have him
Sam Latus - waste of a shirt in my opinion not good enough never will be
Jake Webster -Will look good in yellow shirt suits his heart he hasnt one never seen a player go down so easy big baby
Ben Galea- Past his best too many injuries over the past 2 years should have benn given assistant coaches roll
Jason Netherton- How he ever got extension to hios contract I will never know
Scott Morrell - Too slow now works hard in defence but wew are not good enough to carry him
Joel Clinton- Too many injuries now on his day as good as any in the league but not enough good days
Scott Taylor- Let him go over rated he has dilusions of grandeur, not as good as people say
Liam Watts - Was ruined by Justin Morgan should have been given more game time last year no wonder he asked for move, he must have thought he would be ok with Sanercock
Scott Wheeldon- Was never going to make it not good enough
Dobbo - Word is he wants to go to Hull Fc any one know about this, if he does let him go Lincoln Withers better no 7

Players In

Cory Patterson- Good big forward replace Ben Galea
Cant spell his name but Latest Prop from Knights Test Forward will replace Joel Clinton
Sean Gleeson from Salford will more than replace Webster,he never misses a game

We need the following:-
A winger
B Full back or play Craig Hall there
C Loose forward or play Blake Green there
The other positions I would bring on the kids give them a go

I await your response

What response are you waiting for?

I think perhaps you've watched too much beach volleyball and your testarone is running a bit high.

Some truth, but put excessively harshly. Some of those players have served the club [ivery[/i well and I'll remember them fondly.
Some obvious points, IMO:
Irrespective of whether Dobson wants to go to FC (which I doubt somewhat), Withers is not a better 7.
Taylor; there may be a slight element of over-excitement both about his performances and the prospect of him leaving, but we need to retain as many of our best club-trained players as possible if we're going to have any depth in the squad. If Murrell follows Watts out the door, and Taylor goes too, that's a fair bit of inexperience in the top 25 paid players.
McDonnell wanting more money - he's a professional player, loyalty won't pay his bills.
Webster - speaking of loyalty, it is a bit rich to call him yellow. Fair enough he can maybe wipe away the salt tears with £20s, but he's been good player for us during the club's best spell for nearly a generation.

EH4, did you feel better after that lol?

Whilst it hasn’t been officially announced, you can add Scott Murrell (to Castleford) and Joel Clinton (to Penrith?) to the out-list.

Sam Latus and Jason Netherton are contracted for 2013. IMO both these players aren’t regular first teamers but are good enough to step in for injuries. Every squad needs a stock of this type of player.

You are so wrong about Scott Taylor (delusions of grandeur), he is a very much grounded kid and appreciates the development Rovers have invested in him. Nobody knows what will happen (read the Scott Taylor thread for the forums comments) but lets not put the kid down. He is a young ambitious kid on a big learning curve. IMO he is right to think long and hard about where best to commit the next stage of his career. I hope it is with Rovers.

Re Dobbo going to FC, lets not even go there or even better still ‘over Hudgell’s dead body’!

Re the in-list, we know about three players (Gleeson, Paterson and Tui’) but NH stated the club have signed 5 players. Speculation re the other 2 players is the winger Caro (from London) and cover at 6/7. NH has also stated many times this season Rovers will be promoting youth next season – that’s why CS was brought-in.

I didn't read as far as the Dobbo comment, Lol! Withers isn't even our best 9 and him and Green were fighting for Spanner of the Match last Monday.

Watching rovers for over 50 years? You have my sympathy

In that 50 years he probably watched Rovers beat your lot at Wembley........ Now you have my sympathy.

And he can remind himself everytime he goes into the 10-5 bar.
Would be a bit sad if thats all he can cling to after 50 loyal years though.

Think bit out of order bout scotty Taylor been one of out best players this season I will be gutted if he goes for two reasons one he's of the ginner quota and two he is a fab player

ET or Tui

My response

not sure what you've ever seen from Clinton to suggest he is as good as any in the league or likewise to suggest Withers would be a better scrum half then Michael Dobson!

Agree with CC, I think EastHull4 is just a little clueless

Scott Taylor will be an England regular one day, and I don’t think it will be long before the NRL teams come knocking, if he has one good game against the Aussies then they will be queuing up for him to sign.

If he wants to go, let him!

There is no point keeping a player that does not want to play for you!

Good luck Scott in whatever you decide to do.

Gleeson had a good game yesterday, scored two good try's, looked very dangerous with the ball.

Apart from the last play!

Was it him that threw the ball out of play?

Or did the commentary team get the wrong player?