Again.

gutted great effort how some of them decisions where mad made was staggering
wigan do what great sides do win when not been at there best and that goes down to how rovers played unlucky boys.

Felt a bit sorry for Stuart Cummins on the Sky team tonight having to explain half a dozen baffling decisions without appearing to have a go at the officials.

Pains me to say it, but you guys should have won. Charnley clearly put the ball on the line for his 'try', assuming he actually put it down cleanly. Unlucky. Hope you aren't that good next week

That was a really poor performance for the officials. I find myself in the uncomfortable position of feeling sorry for Hull KR. I'm sure I'll get over it



Seriously very dodgy decision to give that "side line" try

Never a more accurate pre-match summary.

Thought you were well and truly robbed tonight even though it is better for us that you lost. The ref the video ref and the touch judge all got calls wrong tonight in Wigan's favour.

shocking guys best team was robbed AGAIN by incompitent officials

I like it when Rovers lose. I like it more when they lose controversially.

personally i thought that even though we had some calls go against us, i actually thought that some poor decision making by D Hodgson cost us the game, the constant jumping out of the line cost a couple of easy scores and then he had a try pinged for foot in touch and then last few secs and he catches the ball whilst static and then freezes...

Laugh now. Cry next Sunday at about 3.30. After today and the Magic Weekend, we're about due some controversial decisions to go our way.

What is so painful to watch is the fact that James Child has looked over that Charnley try at least four or five times and still gives the try. If it was given by the on field ref with no VR help, then you can understand (maybe) that he would get it wrong.

It's embarassing to see that try given. I was furious and I'm a Saints fan who was hoping that you'd get beat tonight!

What compounded that was the forward pass (apparently) before HT that never was. You should have scored, but it led to Wigan scoring just before HT getting them right back in the match.

Some big calls that influenced the outcome were incorrectly given.

And the team warning and guy in the bin for 10 mins when Wigan just as guilty of messing about at ptb. I been saying for years the RFL are not as impartial as they should be, tonight has not changed my mind!!!

We have a 'free play' the ball is kicked and then comes off a wigan player and goes dead. Goal line drop out given??? FFS at least stick to the rules.

child was tracking the wrong white line apparently

I listened to Michael Dobson on Humberside and full marks to him. He deflected all of Gollum's attempts to get him to blame the referee and said that Rovers lost due to their own indiscipline. Likewise Josh Hodgson.

They did, the greater advantage was from the goal-line drop ouy

How when the ref has no idea how far Wigan will drop out. We could have had a scrum down on the forty whilst Wigan could have booted the ball well over the forty.

tell you one thing you wont half miss dobson when hes gone, he was brill tonight i just wish we had him,

Agreed. But with him gone, the rest of the team will need to think a bit more instead of relying on him.

There's still rumours about Kris Keating, but that's on another thread.

That's 4 points less in the league than you should have due to nothing but inept referees.

How did Charnley get on as far as the away crowd?

I was impressed by HKR tonight.
Love the shirt colours.
The officials were lousy.

The windmill warning thing is a joke.
There is no parameter as to how long it can last.
That clearly makes it subjective and open to BIAS.

I hate Wigan so I'm biassed too.

I don't think there was much of an away crowd to be honest with the glimpses i saw on sky but could be wrong! I didn't hear anything towards charnley aswell but again could be wrong

It'll take a Saints crowd to make him suffer.. He will.

Can't even claim much glory from it. I've seen it so many times from the away end there and as proven tonight it doesn't even matter if the game's on TV the officiating is always the same.