Hull FC would not pay his over inflated price tag, you have no idea if he would be their first choice or even still at the KC.

It is nothing to do with who he plays for, it is the fact he cannot get into any of the teams you mention that tells you he aint a top 7.

He is ok, he does a decent job, but he could not lace Sean Long or Paul Deacons boots. If he was British he would not get in the England squad, or the Yorkshire squad.
I am glad he is at Rovers, he does a decent job and there aint many availble half backs as good as him around that would come to KR but he is nowhere near the best in Britain.

Seriously you don't have to gang up on me. Everyone seems to be getting confused that I am talking about how he has played so far. I realise that in 2008 he was not as good as Burrow, Long and others.

I have given my opinion that in 2009 he will be the best scrum half in the league because having watched him, I think he is something special. I also realise that others will not share my opinion and I can accept that, no problem.

So far no-one has said "I disagree I think Rob Burrow will be the best scrum half because of..........." for example. Constantly hammering Dobson and saying how crap he is will make no difference to me whatsoever.

Nobody is ganging up on you.

Ok, here goes.

I think that Burrow, Long, Deacon, Lulu, and Monaghan are all better players and therefore will continue to make Dobson look ordinary.

Leuluai is one of the most average scrum halves in the game, a great tackler and occasionally does good things but mostly average. I bet most Wigan fans if they were honest (which they won't be) would rather have Dobson back than Leuluai.

Dobson wasn't ordinary in 2008 (four tries in a match, winning goal from the touch line against Wire to name a couple of far from ordinary acts) but neither was he brilliant all the time. KR for a number of reasons in 2008 were hit and miss but I expect them to rectify those problems in 2009.

That is why Brian Noble is coaching Wigan and not you.

If you think Dobson is better than Lulu you are fecking nuts. You have virtually summed it up in your comment. Dobson did some good things in a few games, he was also terrible in a few with people calling for him to be shipped out and Webster brought back, I think on the cuddly forum.

Get some dvd's, sit and watch both players and then come back.

I've seen the DVD where Dobson single-handedly saves Wigan from relegation oblivion.

I am sure his team mates are real pleased to read stuff like that.

Your knowledge of Rugby League is outstanding.

him and the other £200K's worth of salay cap busting signings.

The £450,000 Stuart Fielden was deadwood that season wasn't he

No if he was dead wood he'd have signed for rovers like the rest of our dead wood. The difference is we'd have paid him twice as much.

Bit of a bold statement to say that Dobbo could be MoS next season, but I think he could have a gr8 year, as long as he gets a consistent HB partner.

Are you Justin Morgan



Or just Justins PR adviser





Dobson is good but the best in SL

I don't think Justin would want to put any unnecessary pressure on Dobson so I don't think he'd say anything like what I've said. That's not to say that justin doesn't have the same opinion of Dobson's talent, he'll just get down to hard work and let the fans like me make the predictions.

Dobbo for super league dream team

he called him best in the city only to be outplayed by a Hooker playing out of position

Your only as good as your last derby game....when Dobson and Cooke put dull to the sword....again.

Watched that game over this past weekend and Dobson had a fantastic game, his kicking and passing was bang on.

Berrigan was quiet in that game until he reverted back to the hooking role so hardly an accurate recollection.

so it was tommy lee who out played dobson?

Ok...he got outplayed by Lee....thats even worse

Tommy Lee has a job just playing with himself never mind worrying about out playing the opposition



Never mind,fortunately the powers to be decided to keep him on for another year.

long
burrow
deacon
dobbo
leuluai

Cooke was S**t in that game, Dobson had a great game though, but every player was a couple of good games a season.

Is Tommy saving his up for one 'mega season'?

i thought dobson wasnt anything special in last derby match,in defence he hides out on wing, thought cookie got better as game went on

Yes but for York City nights.