Think Browny should keep his place he gives us a bit more Biff, i am a big Salter fan but i think Hally is a matchwinner so for the Derby he gets the nod at centre with Salter playing against Wigan on Monday.

Oh and we need Paterson to have a stormer i presume he was saving himself on Sunday.

My team would be ...

1. Eden
2. Hodgson
3. Welham
4. Salter
5. Hall
6. Burns
7. Dobson
8. Tuimavave
9. Hodgson
10. Paea
11. Mika
12. Paterson
13. Griffin

14. Carlile
15. Lovegrove
16. Beamount
17. Horne


I still view Brown as a work in progress. His defence and positioning is still questionable and I noticed watching the game back that Hall seemed to be more concerned sometimes with what his wing man was doing rather than the opposition. Seeing as Hull's one and only tactic against Hudds was to kick high I think they’ll employ the same tactic again. So far I have more faith with Latus under the high ball than Brown. So for me Hall gets the nod. (even though he’s prone to silly errors like @ KC last year)

Horne was (for me) our most effective player off the bench last week. Good yards made, and nice footwork shown. Also offers the ‘unwanted’ option to shuffle him into the centres should we need to – injury or something.

The hard decision is Cox/Walker/Beamount. I didn’t think we missed Walker much and thought Cox took the ball up well, same with Beamount. Hull’s main threat to us is their forward dominance. Earlier I was in favour of Cox but on reflection I think we need at least two out and out props on the bench.

The squads been announced and its Adam Walker in for Richie Beaumont, plus Rhys Lovegrove is named in the squad.

IMO the big decision is between Jordan Cox and Graeme Horne; based on his impact in the Castleford game Coxy gets my vote.

The two to miss out - Horne and Salter. Even though I feel Brown has been exposed defensively his 'first receiver' running and his physical threat puts him slightly ahead of Salter.

I see Holdsworth and McDonnell have been left out of FCs 19.

Did Cox have an impact?
The derby calls for composure and I think Horne provides that.
Either way I wouldn't be particularly upset with whichever he chose. Nice headaches to have anyway.

I think I'd go for Horne Tbf and I think that's what he will do we need a good game defensively the rest will take care of itself

It's grt to have Rhys in the squad and walker, I like salter bit gutted there might not be a place for him

A few either-ors but I'd go with:

Eden, Brown, Hall, Welham, Disco, Burns, Dobson, Tuimavave, J. Hodgson, Paea, Horne, Paterson, Griffin (maybe Cox if it is a heavy pitch).

Lovegrove, Walker, Mika, Carlile.

Brown-Hall rather than Hall-Salter mainly for continuity.

I think that Horne will get picked ahead of Jordan Cox. I also think that Salter will come back in place of Alex Brown, with Hally shifting to the wing (fitness permitting).

That cud be an option I just think salter tightens things up in the centre on that side

I'd agree, I like Salter a lot defensively. Didn't see the Cas game but I'd perhaps just edge towards Hall for his experience, penalty kicking for touch and conversions if Dobson's hamstring is still a little fragile.

Having thought about it, and seen the squad, here's my revised team.

Eden
Hodgson
Welham
Salter
Hall

Burns
Dobson

Walker
Hodgson
Tuimavave
Horne
Paterson
Griffin

Carlile
Lovegrove
Mika
Paea

Brown unlucky to miss out but I think Hall provides the X factor we might need and Salter tightens up the defence a bit. I also think that pack allows us to start solidly then bring on Lovegrove, Mika and Paea to impact the game midway through the half.

I'm on my own here as no one else ever says this but I like a balanced prop selection, in that I want a cart horse and a stallion.
Therefore I see Tuimavave and Walker as our cart horses and Lovegrove and Paea as our stallions.
Brilliant analogy that.

Reasonable assessment to be honest.

Er we've got burns to take the conversions

I'd drop hall for salter purely to sure up the edge a bit. Still looks weak defensively but slightly stronger than hall.

Team picks itself. Hall will play Centre for his pace and creativity if nothing else. Eden will play. Walker and Lovegrove were needed to be back for the defence they bring. Fairly easy to pick, its if they can stop it.

Eden
Brown, Hall, Welham, Hodgson
Burns, Dobson
Evarn, Hodgson, Walker
Lovegrove, Paterson
Griffin

Carlile, Horne, Mika, Paea

Its almost the best we have to offer tbh anyways. Hoping the rain and poor weather stays away.

Craig Hall made Jake Webster look like a world beater on sunday i wouldnt have him anywhere near the centres on the wing we might get away with playing him

Game2012 the only change would be to start Paea instead of Walker, we need to get on top early and we certainly wont with Walker.

Only got 1 prop on a very lightweight bench, I'd swap Loveove for Horne.

The chances of our outside backs getting a pass is minimal so wouldn't worry

Dobbos out injured hall to hb

Dobbos out injured hall to hb

Dobbos out injured hall to hb

For three games?