It isnt though is it. I think Briscoe is fantastic and played very well last night, and i like the guy. I just think as a FB in the top league you need more than he offers.

Absolute rubbish, funny how most other teams fans respect him as a top class full back but alot of the Hull fans on RLFans dont. I have many friends who are Hull fans and Ive not heard one claim Hull are better off at full back with out him, just seems to be the Hull fans on here that are of the opposite opinion.

Come on you dont believe that !

Its all about opinions though,personaly I was sorry to see him go.

i saw him interviewed on sky sports news after i got in from the game, he needs to stay off the telly with a face like that, his nose could be used by plastic surgery students

But he did have a great game, one of the bravest about.

and if you watch the break he makes up the middle he gets a slap around the head off Lee Smith before handing on to Dobson (where Sinfield takes the loose ball) another head shot but no pen thou.

I do, and always have done.

Outstanding full back and has the kind of spirt coaches would give a right arm for to have in every player.

Definetly a contender for MOM on Friday IMO.

I love the convoluted disciplinary process:

Incident considered High tackle in 71st minute
Decision No charge
Details of Charge / Reason for NF No high tackle.

It was fairly pointless even asking the panel to consider it as a high tackle.

Is that the hit on Bailey? What on earth was it considered for?

Sinfield probably asked Bentham to put a word in.

Your probably right, or was it Bentahm asking Sinfield if he wanted it on report.

A player was left prone on the ground and none of the officials saw what happened. A more perfect example of how video evidence is of benefit you couldn't wish to see.

What concerns me is the level of incidents being referred against action taken, if you look at this weeks it clear that officials are getting lazy.

I may be wrong but i think any tackle that results in a head injury of some kind has to be reviewed

And like the old saying, if you know youve got nothing to worry about then whats the fuss

The system does allow the referee to avoid making some hard decisions during the match.

Of course there are poitives and negatives , a subsequently deemed wrongful dismissal of a player - still usually results in that team losing the match.

agreed

In some cases it can lead to officials shying away from making a big (but correct) call (Ben Westwood would probably have gone if there wasn't an 'On Report' option, for example). With something like this though, it's perfect. The only person in the ground who will have know what happened, before looking at a replay, was Briscoe, so rather than the officials having to make a call based on no evidence, they can refer it to hopefully make sure than the correct punishment is meted out.

How do you work that out?

Briscoe is a fine fullback and always gives 100% but given the option of the two we had at Hull I am glad we kept Motu, injuries apart.

Opinion is still divided amongst the Hull fans on the Briscoe/Tony debate , with many still questioning the latters ability under the high ball.

Of course Tony does offer more of a utility option , which appeared to be more important to Peter Sharp.

You are Motu's sister and i claim my £5




I wouldn't know which Briscoe v Motu thread to bring up to prove you are in a small minority ......even with your own fans.

Opinion is very much divided, they both are quality players and tbh it matters not about who is in the minority/majority, we have Motu and that is all the counts.

Im delighted we have Shaun in our ranks and hopefully he will be around for many years at Craven Park.
A great player who because of the type of guy he is off the field also makes him a great ambassador for Hull KR.

Couldn't agree more.


Lets hope all those charged are given the appropiate sentence at this evenings disciplinary.

There's a first time for everything, I suppose.

And the view of a small percentage of Hull fans given on an internet forum is representative of the whole population of Hull fans isnt it?