Long been saying he'd do ok. Kept getting shot down.

It is going to take this team time to gel after all we did lose the player that carried us for five years I think in the end we will be ok

john kear

I agree, but time isn't a limitless commodity. I believe/hope that it'll turn. But unless and until it does the screw keeps turning. Alongside the somewhat disappointing results during this very, very tough run of fixtures there's been some quite deeply concerning issues. When it comes together, it might all click beautifully.

To this point though, the new pack looks more heavy than powerful, our edge defence is still erratic and there's not massive potency in the halfs. Plus the tendency to start each half of a match slowly, and have spells where we concede tries in batches has gone on too long to be considered a blip.

Win a couple and it'll look rosier, but performances and results have to improve. 'We're confident and are working really hard to fix things up', is reaching the end of its shelf-life.

Are you saying Rovers are tools?

Edited.

Even I would not wish that on Rovers. There are limits.

I'm sure Sandy is trying his best. No one starts their day saying they're going to try to be rubbish today. The question is whether his best is good enough. But after 3 years of questionable defence and his inability to get these good players (on paper) motivated and working as a team, is it time to let him go before the team is completely sunk?

In the end, we all just want the team to start winning and ultimately it's up to our generous board to make that call.

The aim of this thread was simply to speculate that if the board does make the decision to replace him, who realistically would we like to see take over.

I mentioned Francis Cummins at the start although most of the others also have merit. IMHO I'd like an English coach again, someone experienced and with some fresh ideas.

nope just the coach

The coach hasn't been missing 40 tackles a game maybe just maybe the players should shoulder some of the blame

indeed they should but its not a new issue is it? same faces in general still missing the tackles so if the coach cant fix it, even after bringing his own men in maybe just maybe someone else should have a go at fixing it

Well, as I said I don't really agree with this game, but I don't like to be left out so I'll go for who I wanted last time around.

Keiron Purtill.

Stan or James Webster for me.

Can I ask on what basis?

Legend as he is Stan should be nowhere near a super league head coaches job

James Webster for many reasons:

Legend as a player for us
Did an amazing job as short-term player-coach (e.g. the NRC Final win)
Knows the club very well
Extremely well-respected in east Hull (and even west I sense)
Has gained experience as an assistant at two clubs at least now hasn't he?

Stan:

One of our all-time greats (IMO)
Loved by the club, fans and area
Contacts in England, PNG and maybe Aus

Okay either would maybe be a gamble, but ATM the club is in it's worst position since gaining promotion, and Sandercock (along with many others) have stripped the heart and soul from what was once an RL club and one people cared about. With him in charge we'll be Championship in the very near future, therefore I don't see what there is to lose.

Whilst it's hard to argue that results, and indeed performances haven't been up the expected or required standard how has the heart and soul been stripped from the club, and if so how is Sandercock to blame for that?

I don't believe the heart n soul of the club has been ripped out but i do believe that under Morgan he felt everything the fans felt and he give us a team to be proud of following you just have to look at our away support under sandercock!

I would want him to stay, As someone has compared us to the Man U fans moaning, the one thing their club did at the start of the Ferguson era was to stick with him & we all know how that went. I would stick for a couple of reasons the main one is there are no replacements to come in even if we got rid. If a new boss came in it is still the same squad & would take time to re train (more time than it will take Sandy to turn it round). I said a few years ago that James Webster would be one of the most important signings the club would ever make & he would possibly go on to coach this club to the top, I still believe that to be true but I think he needs a couple of years as an assistant first. I also think Sandy & the club have been unlucky we have had started to produce a few good youngsters who would step up into the first team unfortunately they are playing in other clubs fist teams (Taylor Beaumont & if rumours are to be believed Cox will be off at the end of the season) We have a lot of changes in the side & we should have a bit of faith in the club & its team to sort it out. I don't think we will be in the bottom two but we will be lucky to make the playoffs, Give they guy a chance & review at the end of the season.

Some of you aren't half dull and predictable.
Honestly, how many points did you expect us to be on at this point in the season with the games we have played?
Realistically 90% would've been more than happy with 3 points, which means we are 1 win behind where we should be. If you're willing to call for a coach's head 5 games into a season, as far as I'm concerned, you don't deserve to be watching a successful team.

Well said.

it's not always about the points though, its the performance too, and our performances haven't been anywhere near good enough. after 2/3 seasons nothings changed under CS,

for me a change is necessary.

If it was just five games then fair enough, we're all fickle. It's not 5 games though, he's had a long run with his own players and shown no marked improvement.

Well said and if we do not win the next 2 games starting with Bradford he should pack is bags

You know that game they sometimes do at half time where a random fan goes on the pitch to catch the bombs? Well, sometimes you get the funny guys that are facing the wrong way with their arms out and the ball hits the floor 10 yards behind them? A team of those people could have beaten Bradford by more than 16 today. Bradford were utter shatpank.

No different, poor display.