So he scores more trys and creates more trys than the three scrum halfs who are apparently better than him

Not to mention the 4 40/20s he's kicked as well as the fact the media will present him with the Albert Goldthorpe medal should he avoid a card in tomorrows game.

He'll be the 7 in the dream team and like Burrow will appear in this seasons grand final

Burrow is a very good player, his game is very different to that of Dobson in fact he's not so much an organiser more of an off the cuff genius but this season Dobson is in the much better form of the two

and these are the only criteria by which idiots judge a scrum half,

also would this be the 'creating more try' statistic that somehow has Ali Lauitiiti creating one try all season?

which surely shows the ridiculous the criteria for the albert goldthorpe medal is,

considering in both of its years a scrum half for a 'lesser' (note the inverted commas) team has won it, maybe the award in itself is weighted in favour of that type of player?

would this be the SL dream team which rated George Carmont as a better centre than Senior? and Ade Gardner as one of the best two wingers in SL

you are correct, they are very different players, Dobson in the Leeds team would offer nothing we dont already have from Sinfield and Mcguire,

Dobson is a much more traditional Scrum half who is more comparable to Long or Brough, Long is class act who dominates Saints, and they are going to miss him massively next year, Pryce (imo) is a nothing player at Stand Off, he is superfluous, he takes a winning saints from winning by ten points to winning by thirty but goes missing in close games, i woudl certainly go for long ahead of Dobson,

Brough is a different kettle of fish, depends on what you want, on his day brough is better and he doesnt seem to be phased by a big occassion, Dobson is more consistant, Brough can win a game single handedly and also be absolutely atrocious, Dobson needs a good workmanlike pack to be anything

i wouldnt have any of them in the leeds team though because they simply wouldnt fit into the way leeds play

....and should only be quoted if they appear to favour a Leeds player.

How I've missed you on here Smokey.

not really, any that are open to interpretation should be ignored

the only ones i would put faith in are metres made, trys scored, tackles made, etc, the ones which either are or arent,

the try assist one especially seems to be just picked out of a hat

zzzzzz zzzzzzzzzzz zzzzzzzzzz

The fact Smokey disagrees is a massive endorsement of it being true.


On this seasons form Dobson has been the best No 7 in Super League.

sorry, i forgot, why bother with debate or an opinion its the hull kr board


Hull FC are well rubbish innit and Dobson is proper good, them hull fc must be well annoyed!

is that better?

But but but but form is temporary and all that

it is indeed, hence why you are still miles behind us and Saints even though both teams have been god awful for the best part of this season

Sadly being 5 points behind you won't stop us lifting the trophy

no, but not getting to the GF will,

We'll be facing you at Old Trafford

no, you wont,

it will be leeds and saints, the only team who could break that up are wigan,

no one else has the experience

It's ok, we'll go to Saints turn them over for the 3rd time this season and have a home game to make the GF

We've got players who have played in Cup and Grand Final games so we'll cope

how many? 4?

how about we put money on it?

leeds, saints or wigan make up the GF, i win

anyone else, you win?

Briscoe
Walker
Cooke
Fozzard
Newton
Galea
Fitzhenry
Vella


Gene played in the WCC

Plus Netherton, Cockayne, Fisher, Murrell, Aizue all played in the National League GF under massive pressure to lead us on the road to where we are now.

Leeds are by far and away the team to beat but it's not a forgone conclusion as to who the participants will be.

Briscoe and Cooke were smashed in the only GF they have played, which they got to by default to be honest, (the whole league bar saints were appalling that year, as opposed to this where the whole league is appalling) Newton was a peripheral figure signed by far and away the best team half way through the year,

and none of them have played together




well done stan, its hardly the GF though







it never is,

but as i said i dont think there is a realistic chance of any besides those three getting there, (other than les catalans which ill admit is a hope rather than an expectation) besides, Hull KR really arent 'that' good, they are workmanlike which is, unfortunately, good enough for third/fourth this year

Its 2 for the price of one on Dummies at Mothercare.
Stock up Smokey because on Monday Dobson will be in the Dream Team and Burrow wont.

wow, the dream team, really, wow,

that is fantastic, wonderful, he must be better than johns at his peak

i would definately swap a GF win for Burrow being in an imaginary team, thats well good that is



btw, why are you checking the price of dummies at mothercare, thats a bit wierd

It's ok, We have established your somewhat bizarre hatred of Hull Kingston Rovers before now.

i dont hate any team, i love all rl teams, even dirty bradford,

i just dont think you are as good as you think you are,

Well we have been doing something right, i'm enjoying the ride

You just couldn't make it up!

well you certainly lack imagination

Yes folks, the imaginative people who gave you JJB, Keith Senior and Lee Smith now proudly present "Dirty Bradford".