You mean like how the RFL took the points away from Leeds after Tanseygate?

Oh wait...

There's no guarantee that Rovers would have drawn. Hull could still have gone on to win had the penalty been given. If you believe this "reliable source" in the slightest (or believe anyone else will believe it) then you're an absolute pleb!

Great effort by all the lads,
Best team on the day.
Very proud to be a Red&White.

If the RFL gave us a point back then I would snatch their hand off, Not that I think they will for 1 minute.
Last years cock up was for a forward pass, unfortunatly forward passes are part of our game and happen week in and week out. And it didn't cost Fc the game.
Gansons offside cock up,which actually did cost us the game, shouldn't have happened as he had time to check it over and over again.
Apart from Ganson being involved the two incidents are totally different in comparision.

Total double standards there, how can you say one decision didn't cost us the game but the one on Saturday did, when the try was scored, their was a few minutes left in which anything could have happened.

If you get the point then that would be a bigger mistake than the one Ganson made.

Not double standards at all.If ours had been a forward pass decision then fair enough.
I don't see how anyone can even compare the decisions.
Forward passes are missed in every game,Hull FC aren't the only team to have a forward pass decision go against them resulting in a try,and they won't be the last. We went on to score another 2 tries,which is what cost you the game.
The offside error has [unever[/u been made by a VR before as it is simple and clear to see that Green was offside and even if Ganson tracked the wrong man,then surely he saw that the player he tracked didn't score the try!!!!
This error will probably never happen again.
That is why Martin Offiah and others are calling for Ganson to get the sack,
That is why Tomkins,Bailey,Pryce and loads more RL players are saying its the WORST decision they have ever seen. This mistake is on a totally different level to a forward pass.

Good post Easty for the most part.
I must say I was impressed by your performance on Saturday. Like most I thought we started as favourites and once again we just could not deliver at Magic. I don’t think we turned up as the team who have played so well recently, but that is also in large part down to the immense effort of the Red and Whites.

I feel we will come back from this and get back into gear. However it bamboozles me exactly what happens to your lot in the week before Magic. You really do come out a completely different team, (apart from last year) and on Saturday I thought you looked as intense as any team we’ve played this year.

Overall you deserved to win the game.

Your attack looked speedy and dangerous, and I thought we did well to keep you out. But it was your defence that surprised me. All season you’ve been moaning about it and yet it shows you can defend as well as any top side when the team is in the zone.

How do you get that consistency into your game ??? If you could deliver performances like that each week it would guarantee fringes of top 4 never mind scrambling about in 9th 10th spot.

I think Sandercock can coach. He’s just taking his time getting there in my opinion, and that could be his downfall sadly. He’s done wonders for your attack and if he could do the same for your defence as he clearly did on Saturday then you may well already have your man. He just may look back and wish he sorted both out together, Just could be difficult now coaching how to keep the other ball in the air, without dropping the first one.

But if he can sort out the defence to Saturdays levels maintain Saturdays intensity levels and build consistency then you will be right back up there.

Considering you lost George early on and then Lovegrove who was having a really good game it was an even more impressive effort than the scoreline suggests. And maybe that’s what lost you it on Saturday because we smash and grabbed in the last 7 minutes. Don’t get me wrong, I was truly elated at our win, at the end I went berserk and was truly amazed that sport can bring such low and high emotions. But I’m one who wants both sides of the City to be a force. I just want us to be a bigger force.
Bottle up what that team of yours had on Saturday and you wont be far off. And if we can stay one step in front we’ll be a champion team which is where I want us to be and where I think were going.
A brilliant nerve jangling game of RL and a great effort by your side, one for you to be proud of.

The least said about the VR the better. You win and lose on such decisions but that one was as bad as I’ve ever seen.
Ganson made the mother of cock ups and he should lose his job for it. I wont wait for it. Neither will I wait for for RedHall to sort out so many other very poor decisions that are seriously effecting our great game.

Well done anyway, very unlucky on the day. It was just our turn to get away with it this year and smoke the cigar.

And Rovers might have only needed a drop goal if the scores had remained 16-all, so lets not go down that path.

Any RFL intervention would set the wrong type of precedent so lets move on. The mistake lies with the officials not with FC.

Yes it was a vastly improved 'effort' by Rovers but now they have to reproduce it against the Bulls. That will be the acid test although the injury list is looking even more ominous with Lovegrove and George very doubtful.

WELL done sir a decent hull fan not to many come on this board well said

It was more in response to some of your fans saying Ganson cost them the "points" (indicating they thought they'd go on to win). That path has already been trodden, I was just letting them see the alternative path.

Agree with the rest though.

thought the tackling by rovers in the last 2 derbies was top notch, but where is the effort in some matches , no consistency is a worry

the post from uppo58 was easily the best one I have seen, now lets all agree ganson cost us the game last year,and cost you the game on Saturday.the man should not be in any position whatsoever in the game, lets move on!!

Not really your problem is it but thanks for the concern

Some cracked up crystal meth addict mate won't help you in this one.

They have no mandate to remove the points from Hull FC. That can only be done if Hull FC agree to it as the mistake was not Hulls. Same with Bradford vs Leeds.

Even if they did, we would only loose 1 point as we were drawing at the point of the decision.

Not that its going to happen, and if it did the RFL would be run out of authority by every club chairperson, but it would be ludicrous from a sporting perspective as well as there was time left at the end of the game in which either club could have responded to the situation of Hull been disallowed the try.

Can't believe it's over 48 hours since the event, and still hardly anyone is asking how Rovers managed to blow a ten point lead with eight minutes to go.

Indeed.

Well done Sir. A Very good read and nothing I can disagree with.

we didn't really did we we was robbed as everybodys excepted the same last year when nobody mentioned how you blew a 16pt lead with 14 mins left you just talk about Dobsons flat pass

Hang on, forget about the last try. At the end of the day, with eight minutes to go you were ten points up, even if the Green try had been chalked off, it would still have been a draw. Your team were gash for the last fifteen minutes when the pressure was put upon you and you eventually cracked, the Green try is a convenient excuse for another Sandy led second half throw away.

we were down to 15 fit players for the last 20mins Yeamans try was disputable and a blatant knock on in the lead up to the try we were going to crack in the end and concede at least one try and you still haven't explained how you blew a 16 pt lead last year with 14mins left though

To answer your last bit a joke forward pass, a guy being stretchered off while being scored against down his channel and finally some diabolical defence by the now departed Will Sharp.

Well, then there's the forward pass in the build up to Hall's try and then the penalty that should never have been meaning after Yeamo's not even slightly debatable try it should have been 16-14. And this come back after we had lost our most influential player this year so far.
Staffs has more than adequately explained us blowing our lead last year, now how about you? How many times have you blown leads in the second half under Sandercock?

the game was a mirror image of last year then really to be fair I loved it last year and I just knew he was going to give that try even when theres no way in a million years it should have been but swings and roundabouts sh t happens

to be honest only a couple weve usually been chasing games and coming up short the 2 games I remember are the wigan one 26-0 up and Bradford 24-8 up apart from that I cant think

You are forgetting Salford mate