WHOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOSH

I never tend to look for the negatives and always look for positives and I believe if you play SL you have something to offer. I am never overly critical of anyone and don't wish to get in to the " not good enough for my club" mentality like the minority of some of them over the river.

Really pleased that Josh is doing well for you guys. The deal has certainly benefited everyone concerned. I've seen Josh just get better and better since he first played for Wigan's academy a few years ago.I've been told many times just how hard he works at his game and in training, so its great to see him getting the plaudits for his performances.

Hopefully he will stay on loan with you till the end of the season, but I'd like to see him come back for next season and get an opportunity in our 1st team. I've a feeling once he gets in, he'll be really hard to shift.

PMC. Listen to me. He's RUBBISH! You can do better than Charnley. Cut him loose.

You wish

Ti's true i tell ya.

Bobbing along speaks the truth. 99.9% of Rovers fans think he's rubbish. Three lucky tries on Sunday and four in four games means nowt.

Do yourself a favour get Wigan to get rid....and if he's passing East Hull JM may just be interested in giving him a run out...in the reserves.

Why would Justin sign him for Hull?

Darrell Goulding played against us for Salford at the DW Stadium last season iirc.

Charnley will hopefully stay at HKR for the remainder of this season and continue his speedy development. As for next season I can really see him pushing hard for a place at Wigan. It wouldn't suprise me to see him push guys like Goulding for that right wing spot and he may be able to make it his own until a centre spot becomes available.

I'd let him play against us in a couple of weeks time and would do that regardless of league positions. I always think if you have the conviction to send out a lad on loan because you can't fit him in your side then you should have the guts to allow the lad a chance to play in each and every game he can.

Absolutely. In fact you should have the guts to leave him out on loan for an extra season.

TBF I reckon the game against Wigan will be a dead game for the pies anyway as they should tie up the hubcap next week. A run out against Wigan will do him good. Not sure if they'll let him play against them at old trafford tho'.

Theres every chance they will I suppose. Alot will depend on wheather Amos Roberts is still at Wigan next year because theres a few rumours going around that he'll be heading home so we'll have to wait and see on that one.

If he does go home then the fullback position will be filled by either Richards or Sam Tomkins and a position on that left wing could open up for Charnley. He looks to be playing well enough to push somebody like Goulding for a spot aswell.