You mean like Scott Wheeldon did at Hull KR.

Who do you rate more?

Let's face it, you're not going to meet your British players quota through your own academy are you - how did they go yesterday?



Hall vs Wheeldon is about even at the moment IMO. Wheeldon showed some great form at the end of last season and is wanted by Bradford. Hall is a natural instinctive try-scorer but needs to bulk up as he is regularly flicked into touch and can be shown up defensively.

When did this happen,seen no news relating to this recently.The only thing I can find remotely similar to this is the P.Cooke story were Paul WAS found guilty by the RL of having made an ilegal approach to HKR,supposedly while under some kind of contract at FC.At the same hearing HKR were found to have no charge to answer regards TAPPING UP!!
HTH

Shhhhhhhh

1) I never said they did "pull out of a deal".

2) I said they never took up the opportunity of "tendering an offer" (of which every club was given an opportunity) - there's a massive difference.

3) Why can you not understand this point?

Something you've made up in your head - not mine...

Alright, Hull KR never withdrew from "tendering an offer" to Shaun Berrigan due to a poor reference.



Common sense tells you why they didn't try to sign Shaun Berrigan and its green!

You've strengthened massively in many areas, its pretty obvious that Hull KR would not have been able to get Berrigan under their cap and restrictions without the ridiculous suggestion that it was due to a poor reference.

Your opinion counts for nothing as proved below...


Coming from a fan of a club who scored the least number of points this season - wake up and smell the coffee...

Think you need to wake up. You have been shown up with a lot of ridiculous posts.

Err, for the 4th or 5th time, yes they did...


No, the guy who told me wasn't green.


As I've already stated, any interest in the player would have been persued on the basis that he signed as a centre so therefore money for either Webster/Walker would have been used so therefore your point is a completely redundant one.


Look mate. The whole arguement is getting tedious. I know the above to be true, you believe it not to be true. Why not spend your time and energy debating with your fellow fans about why your own team is going down the pan?

Only in the context of a few fc fans choosing to disagree with the posts due to their lack of inteligence to understand the specific stage that interest was not persued in the player.

Lets get back on topic then guys.
Hall is taking a bit of flak over on the Hull forum for his defence and positional play.
He could turn out to be a good player but in the grand scheme of things id say Gibson at Leeds is a better prospect at the moment and they have a ready made replacement for Grandad Keith when he goes.

Leeds are the one club producing an abundance of quality backs.

Hall, Gibson, Smith and co all have an abundance of pace...

Well considering he is a Rovers supporter,it wouldn`t be exactly a shock.

Justin could sort out his defensive frailties.

I'm just waiting for the other reasons Hull KR didn't sign players. I hope world class Rugby League players are good a filling out application forms otherwise Hull KR won't have any players!

We have two centres of better quality signed ofr next season so I can't see it happening. He may replace Fitzhenry but as he isn't really a winger and Fitzhenry is also signed for next season that isn't likely. There is simply no room for him in our squad for next year.

IMO we will be looking for two props, a utility player and a world class scrum half if one became available. Other than that we will see a very setlled squad for the next 2-3 seasons I reckon.

RoidRage.



You dun'arf seem to be on the defensive here Zod my old son. Seems even your own fans are again'st your posting crud and your backing yourself into a corner without their defence to support you. Just do what Dave M did and give up

Still undecided about Gibson, he's okay just now but he has never had a proper run in the side for anyone to judge him.

He won't hang around forever and with Senior signing an extension then its time for Gibson to either force his way in or maybe leave. He needs to be playing like Yeaman, Hall, Atkins and Goulding.

As proven by the first half defensive masterclass at Craven Park last time out. Bet Lockyer learnt a few things

I'll post what I want within the AUP.

If you've got a problem with that, then come and see me personally unless of course, you are a spineless coward of a keyboard warrior which I consider you to be...

tut, tut, tut, zoddy. take a deep breath and calm down. anger management classes maybe in order!

as long as they have signed on the dotted line Justin will fill in the rest of the form

I'm chilled mate.

I just find it strange that a someone who works at the same place would chose to vent his issues on an internet message board instead of coming to see me personally.