Easy to solve, if we have home advantage switch the game to Wembley

simplz

Could well happen if both clubs reach their potential this year.

Its a frightening thought, the excitement surrounding the game would be huge for everyone.

Its a great thought the excitement would be top notch

I'd love to see it, especially if it was the Grand Final !

Excellent thought,although I don`t know if my nerves could stand the build up to the game.

It'd be one of those games that would be the best ever if we won but a complete nightmare if we lost. It'd certainly add a few grey hairs.

Now heres one, if the playoff was at craven park could we expect more than 600 hull fans or would they still not turn up in numbers because of the view from the south stand?

I think we all know the answer to that one!

I'd up the South stand to £50 with no concessions and ban their bloody mascot for good measure

Believe me you don't want to go through with it!

It was bad enough being 80mins away from old trafford twice at Leeds and Losing but going to saints thinking we would win and then losing the way we did took ages to get over, infact I'm still not over it, I will not get over it untill we beat them!

The thing that really hurt about that Saints semi was we didn't really turn up.

Saints weren't very good and we managed to be worse which was hard to take after playing pretty well the week before at HKR. Even playing poorly we still had our chances to win and nearly nicked it at the end...........that made it even worse.

The players never looked like they thought they could win it.

As for a play off game between the Hull clubs.....that would be a great event which every rugbyleague fan would like to see.

I think Joel Tomkins may feel he has alot to make up after his missed chance. We should of wrapped that game up! At the end of the day though we didn't put points on the board and did not deserve it!

I would love a play-off tie at our place against Hull KR!

You where lucky. At least you could go home to a different town.

Thanks for all your comments on this subject, I can see that most of you have the same hopes and fears as me.

I would also like to see the two sets of supporters get together and do something for charity if a big play-off or cup final game came our way. It would be great PR for both sets of supporters (we do get bad press sometimes).

Here’s hoping for a big derby day at the end of the season.

I go to church in St Helens, there is probably around 25 people willing to make me more depressed after we have lost

Not sure I would be able to take the stress.

As regards the south stand, why bother with it. A disgrace. If I could not get in the condemned North stand, I would watch it on sky with Hull fans.

The Stand that obtained all safety licence requirements last Friday and was used v Salford you mean.

Would be great, that or a CC cup would be fantasic for the city would get everyone really hyped up.

To answer the question about the South Stand, I think it would sell out, but I wouldn't go in there and wouldnt blame anyone who doesnt, when I go to watch rugby I want to be able to see the game, this isnt possible in your South Stand, would be happy to go in any other stand for the game, won't be going anyway too far away

Yeah that's the one. If its still standing in April I might utilise it

A challenge cup tie and if possible a semi final between the 2 Hull clubs would be great for the competiton and may bring abit of life back to the trophy pre final(the finals always great and has lost no magic imo).

I thought the recent Manchester derby in the Carling cup was fantastic for that competition and a Hull Derby could do something similar for us.

If there was a semi between the 2 clubs i'd imagine it'd bring in quite a crowd.

Held at elland road perhaps?

Thats the thing, all these people who go one about Saints/Pies or Leeds/Bradford derbies they are still different towns. I forgot how it was living overseas for so long but its crap when you come to work on monday morning and have to hear all the Reds crowing! On the other hand, if you win (which we have not done a lot since i have been back) its fantastic!

Somewhere along those lines would be great and to me it'd be an event that not only Hull people could attend and enjoy.

I'd love to go to a game like that.

You 2@!!

funny though