www.thisishullandeastriding.co.u ... story.html Hope we can get it done

www.thisishullandeastriding.co.u ... story.html Hope we can get it done

Excellent signing if it comes off, certainly your best signing and one of the better signings in SL, cant understand why they are looking to offload him, after him getting a new deal last year on the back of some excellent form.

He still has work to do on his game as he is prone to a lot of mistakes. personally I would have preferred to sign him over Mcdonell

Will be a cracking signing if it is true.

I can almost hear a sigh of relief from the Craig Hall doubters

Be interesting to see where Hall plays when all are fit, I still think his best position in left centre, that was the position that he looked best at while at Hull.

If craig starts well at 6 i see no reason why not to keep him there and put burns at 13!

If he was 'the next Billy Slater' why didn't Brown take him to Saints for when Wellens retires? Now Scott Grix is taking his place at Hudds, and he's surplus to requirements.

Very fast, but you'd have seen less errors playing Hall there.

I will believe it when he's paraded in a shirt, and not before. The Giants must be daft to even consider it. Bags of potential and to focus on his errors to date is just nit picking. Young player in debut SL season makes a few errors, so what? That's part of the learning curve.

Nathan Brown hasn't done him any favours with that Slater comparison.

Paul Andersons lost the plot!

I hope so... a young up and coming english fullback, cant be bad. Would,nt have a problem with hall at fullback either, did,nt rate mcdonnell anyway.

Good signing if true. Sir Stan has it right too imo

A really exciting young fullback, i can't believe the Giants will let him go.

Great signing, this kid has it all!

That's the way I'd be going. Craig Hall needs to be in midfield & you can put 4 forwards on the bench then.

Eden needs a bit of work but he's got a heap of talent. Young full backs are often a bit error prone. 18 months ago Ben Barba was comical under the high ball, now look at him!

Hope this happens, can't understand Huddersfields thinking here.

OTT a tad,you might have seen him play 2 or 3 times at best his stats don't suggest he has it all although he is certainly better than you had IMO

Eden is 3rd choice full back for giants next season behind grix/murphy so can see it being true, eden could of found himself playing at batley all season!

anderson doesnt seem to be a fan, when he took over last season he dropped him.

not all fans were happy with eden anyway last season...error prone and positional sense poor!

but has great potential.

you must of offered us some good cash though too

He must have had some say in giving him a contract to the end of 2015 - new coach, but it was a planned succession.
Circumstances and opinions change, of course. Good signing for us (hopefully

), you have other options so it all makes sense.

Whose taking over from The Giraffe at stand off?

Hope you've got space at HKR for Eden's ego...the lad is a world beater in his head and an egg beater on the park.

Forget the sour grapes and negativity, if this is true (and I and many others hope it isn't) then you will have a fantastic English talent on his way.

He is nowhere near 3rd best fullback at Giants and to have him behind Grix a man who couldn't catch or tackle last season is laughable.

Eden makes errors, drops the odd high ball, so does Tomkins and Billy Slater!!! Hardaker at Leeds was another who looked lost and next minute he is a very good fullback who has represented his country, Eden has the potential to be a lot better.

I could also see him develop into a Danny McGuire type stand off (without the sulking hopefully) he has pace to burn and can spot a gap, to sum up if its true the Giants have yet again shot themselves in the foot and you will have another good player with potential to become great.

Ot but Walker is gonna make a good one too and could emulate what Chris Hill as done.

Giraffe?!



brough and robinson combo

lunt and faiumu hooking combo

Ah, yes. Forgot about Robinson, I was thinking that Grix might play there again. I can see the reasoning, with those four and Cudgoe also able to play fullback if required then I can see how his lack of versatility might make Eden surplus to requirements.

He has agreed terms he will be with HKR next year.

Not sure he will reach those hights but totally agree we should not be letting him go and he has shown enough in his fairly few SL apperances that he is the sort of guy you want to be looking to sign rather than sell and unless there is another signing coming in to replace him do not see it as good business at all.


Perhaps there is an attitude or personality issue with Anderson but on the face of it a good move for KR and a bad one for Giants I would say.

Two good signings in a row now, and 4 good signings out of 6 in my opinion. I'd much rather have Eden than McDonnell. Both clubs should do better than last season.