After saturdays fiasco I felt I had to add my opinions on the refereeing standards we have to put up with. I agree with the comments on this forum Green being offside was a equaliser after last years Ganson mistake.But surely we shouldnt have to put up with mistakes from referees. If they make a mistake they seem to think SORRY is sufficient,yet if a player makes a mistake, an accidental high shot,and most of them aren't, they do not go to the video ref to see if it was a high shot,no its a penalty straight away.Salford got fined for having an extra man on the field who's fault was it really,the officials.The man man on the touchline is supposed to manage who goes on and comes off the field.
FORWARD PASSES, this is getting,for want of a better word,A JOKE,The Hull FC v Warrington game there was 22 forward passes in that game Hull scored 3 tries from forward passes. Warrington 2.Yesterday Huddersfield scored 2 tries from forward passes Wigan 2.Huddersfield 3, Danny Brough seems to get it away with it he ran across the field yesterday and threw it in front of him for the second rower to score on one occasion.Rovers scored 2 tries from forward passes against Wakefield.
I can't understand what the touch judges are there for they don't seem to have input, only very rarely do they tell the referee it was a forward pass.You can see it from the terraces never mind 5 yards away. The positioning of the player passing the ball's hands tells it all, if his wrists dont bend its a forwad pass it is physically impossible to pass a ball backwards running forwards if your wrists do not twist to send the ball behind the body.Nevermind these so called flat passes,the rule states the ball shall be passed in a backwards direction,or have they changed yet another rule.
PLAY THE BALL. Not many players actual play the ball correctley,most of the top 4 teams do not play it and Wigan are the worst offenders. They just put it on the floor and walk over it.
Ther is more but I am depressing myself feel like slashing my wrists,mind I would be able to pass forward easier if I did. The Powers that be have got to get it sorted,referees are killing the game it is costing teams points,players money,if they get win or loss bonuses now adays I don't know, and coaches jobs.

If you're going to sit and count all forward passes in games, you really need to get a life!

Can't say I've noticed any particularly bad decisions recently...

Hmm, interesting observation. I wonder, does easthull4 have a clip board and is called Simon?

I think refereeing standards as a whole have dropped in the last three or four seasons. The prevalence of forward passes is very frustrating.

I'm not sure what else people think can be done after this weekend; Ganson has privately spoken to Hudgell to apologise, the RFL have issued a public apology (which was practically thrown back in their faces seeing as Hudge' took exception to it coming from an ex Hull FC player) and Ganson was stood down from his next VR job as punishment. What really would appease the average Rovers Fan ? A public flogging for Ganson, overturning the result or being awarded the point that you may or may not have lost ?

I hear a comment similar to this every season without fail. When were these halcyon days of better match officiating? There's always been forward passes, dodgy decisions, etc.


Like I said before, I don't understand what Hudgell is hoping to achieve with his comments? All he has achieved is showing his pettiness.

he really is doing himself no favours,

Refereeing in RL has always been poor. It's just thrown into sharper relief nowadays with televised games and multiple camera angles.

So Ganson apologised, the RFL said sorry and Ganson was dropped from his VR appointment yesterday. Is that enough? Are we happy with that? Should the person that's been put in a role at the head of referees make these simple mistakes? Should he lose his job?

I think he should, I don't think SKY are too happy with him either, Stevo in particular. We'll see on Tuesday. They did mention that the RFL will make a statement on Tuesday following their review and also said that the whole incident "is far from over", so, more news to come.

Ganson sacked? Game replayed? Point given to Rovers? Who knows, lets wait and see.

None of them things will happen, and you're stupid if you think they will.

Do you think Ganson should keep his job?

I think the problem we have with referees is the inconsistancy,take wigan leeds last night ,in my opinoin no-one was obstructed but an obstruction was given against leeds late in the game ,but in next weekends games we will see half a dozen pretty simular incidents not given thats what annoys me.#banthegan

Yes I do, it was a mistake.

I expect that there'll probably be an investigation that will lead to two VR's in the future. These kind of mistakes happen, look at the Inglis try in SOO last year.

The most annoying thing for Leeds fans was 5 minutes later Wigan did the same thing, but because it never resulted in a try it wasn't given. That's the problem.

You're the first person I've seen say he should keep his job, maybe that's because his decision was in your teams favour. Neutral fans appear to have the same opinion as me. His position is untenable. Get rid.

Beginning of every season, the RFL pick on something, lasts a few rounds then its back to normal, this year - playing the ball correctly.

I watched 5 games and probably noticed 2 or 3 correct PTB.

I believe in second chances.

Instead of looking to blame people, look at your own teams inability to keep a ten point lead with eight minutes left.

How many second chances is he allowed?

This is the first mistake of this nature.

It's fair to say the team were out on their feet. Used an interchange with a minute gone, shuffled the team around and lost our best performing forward with the last quarter of the game to go.

I'm not unhappy with the performance. I wouldn't have minded if you'd put 3or 4 fair scores on us with 10 to go, the effort from the boys was there.

"First mistake of this nature", class.

He can put that on his CV when he's looking for a new job.

We put three scores on you after our most influential half and player of the year so far had also gone off injured with twenty minutes to go.

So this mistake was on a par with missing the forward pass last year? I'm glad you've clarified that as all your fans on here seem to have a differing opinion.

Sorry, who went off?

I don't follow Hull FC, I don't know who plays well for them or who makes a difference. Did Gareth Ellis play?

Seriously, who went off? Maybe you shouldn't play him if you scored 3 without him.

As I don't know or care about the FC players and form, my opinion on our own performance stands, proud.

Wow, a minute a go he had done nothing wrong until his VR decision. Didn't take you long to think of something, did it?

Sack him.