The poster has made some valid points to be honest and Sharp came in and had to endure a horrid time player wise.......Cooke legged it.....not his fault.

Thackery gate........not his fault.

Brough liking the beer and doing a joke that Backfired.....Doing his job.

Kings antics........Board not backing Sharp up when he wanted rid...not his fault.

Had the backing of the players he had left.....he knew we had a massive problem with S/H and brought Head in for a short stint and Dykes,when fit was clearly a class act,but his injuries caught up with him.....Agar signs Thorman who couldnt lace Head/Dykes boots.

Maiva was a disaster and Briscoe...depends which story you believe.

Player recruitment was poor but was he working with what the board would pay out and had to get the players he did.....i would have liked to have seen him with the recruitment we have for 2010 and he also brought the youth along as well.

Yet it still managed to get to contest 1 of the only 2 trophys you can win.

Out of the 3 coaches since Bomber left...Sharp was the unlukiest to get the boot and was the ONLY coach to have the dressing room and respect of the players and he was a damn sight better talker than Agar....his humour was spot on.

So anyway, Rule out!

And Agar.

TBH i dont mind him but he/they pulled the trigger quicker with 2 previous coaches and Agar justifies being sacked more than 1 of them did....this is his biggest downfall.

A mute is a better talker than Agar.

I liked PS and I always thought that he was an amusing guy. Probably a better coach than Agar but his recruitment and retention was absolutely pi$$ poor !!!

I have many times Sharp was unlucky, agree he made some errors and at times we played some e.....but i had faith in the guy, faith that despite the the stuff he had to deal with he would have us up there or thereabouts in the league....Agar on the other hand........

They have to ,hoping Agar can turn it around next season to save themselves from ridicule for selecting a "cheap option" as coach.

does anyone think if we lose every game between now and the end of the season that Agar might get the boot

If we dont manage another win I would hope Agar would do the decent thing and resign anyway!!!

No. He appears Teflon coated and will be here next season. He survived with three wins from sixteen games and one home win in five months.

That's a good point, maybe if we lost every game his personal pride would mean that he did the decent thing and walked. I could handle losing to Rovers tomorrow if it meant this would happen, the season's dead anyway.

seems that way,plus the clear out to follow yet.

Thats not gunna happen.

There are very few people that would walk away from their jobs in this ecomonic climate!

You thought sharp was hsiit as well then?

so on that basis, Sharp head coach, Agar Director of rugby!?

So he has no personal pride then?

would you walk out on your job,he does have a family to look after like the rest of us,hes still got unfinished business.

If I was as bad at my job as agar is at his then I'd have been out of work a long time ago. He isn't capable of finishing the business he needs to

At most other clubs, Agar would have already gone but the club want to be proved right in his appointment. Especially after sacking two coaches in the last three seasons.

There can't be many coaches in the SL era that have a worse % win ratio. What is his ?? 20% or less perhaps ??

Not quite [ithat[/i bad, but bad enough.

In Super League it's played 34 won 13 lost 21 which is 38%.

If you look at the record against Leeds, St Helens, Wigan and Warrington it's played 11 won 1 lost 10.

And in our fantastic 15 or 16 game run this season, we have only beaten Celtic, Salford and Cas !!!