not sure, it may be a case of us being spoiled by having 2 of the best kickers in the league play for us recently, namely ticks and foster. anyone know his kick percentage?

its not just the percentages though is it, its nailing key kicks under pressure

Yes. Mrs Kosh hasn't stopped mentioning it since the final whistle.



Think we've been spoiled with Tickle knocking them over from all parts. DJ needs to up his game.

We have to remember that Holdsworth is just establishing himself in the team. He has had a spell out that has put him behind where he would want to be. Add the extra pressure of goal kicking to win the game at a magic derby and you can perhaps forgive him at the moment. That said, if he is to retain the kicking duties, you would expect his form to improve with game time and confidence. His kicking from the hand is top banana though!

Haha - love it!

Wonder if he actually got the call though.

Jon Sharp has just become a legend in my eyes

He's got no hair. But we really don't care.

Interesting comments on Super League back chat. Should Gareth Ellis have got together with Dobbo and allowed Rovers to regather the ball from the kick off after the try and walk in unopposed under the sticks to allow the game to finish as a draw?
A more interesting suggestion, and one that would gain Hull FC widespread respect throughout the sporting world, would be to offer a replay at the KC with all gate receipts going to charity. The publicity this would receive for Hull FC and the game in general would be massive. Exiles weekend perhaps?

The decision to award the try was nothing to do with Hull FC so we owe the Dobbins absolutely nothing!

Should Rovers have allowed FC to score an unopposed try last year after the Dan Marino pass?

Shows what a ludicrous programme Back Chat can be.

It wasn't our fault the try was given. Just like it wasn't Rovers fault that the try from the NFL pass was given last year. Was we offered a replay for that bit of daylight robbery? No, we wasn't.

This really needs to be dropped now IMO. Let the RFL have their inquest into the standard of refereeing (and rightly so) but any suggestions Hull are at fault for this are ridiculous. We are not the first team to benefit from a controversial decision and we won't be the last.

So we should replay the game, a game that was a draw until that point, and risk losing that point! You'd be punishing the wrong people. Rod Studd is as big an idiot as Eddie & Stevo put together and back chat is an absolute joke of a show.

Oh dear. Take this year's game as a replay of last year's. We're now even.

Maybe we should replay Leeds v Bradford on the same day as a double-header and then restate the 2007 table? Would possibly need to then replay all the end of season playoffs as well.

I think we should replay the play off game where Tommy Martyn's head touched the whitewash. We'd almost certainly win that one now.

Why dont you say what else was said...Andy Wilson was virtually laughing at the suggestion and said where do you stop.Just get over the fact that your team cant play for 80mins and was hanging on at the end.Studd also said that if Eden had caught the ball,we wouldnt be having this discussion...Stevo then said yeah but he didnt get 4 chances too like ganson did,Studd replied "he still wouldnt have caught it"

But to be fair, at least Ganson made an [iattempt[/i at doing his job.

Cant even call Slaters...sorry,Edens an attempt....he is frigging useless,as it that sack of $hite they have at 6

I missed that as I was in Canada, so a replay suits me

I wonder if your coaching staff and players have moved on and are focused on Bradford and aren't still banging on about the derby like the fans are.

An interesting pic on twitter shows Hall was offside by as much as Green for his interception. Both tries cancelled, we still win. Jobs a good 'un