Now that would leave me (and a few others) with a very interesting dilemma.

On the one hand I would know it was exactly what we SHOULD do.

On the other it would mean Agar was letting the internet forum make his selections, which would be about the final nail in the coffin in terms of any respect he gets.

Obviously coaches should not be persuaded purely by internet forums but what other methods do fans have for expressing their views.

The point is that because so many fans are demanding these selections they can't all be wrong. Agar should know without looking on this message board that this should be done, but, because in Whiting's case it should have happened weeks ago, I can't see it happening.

agree,but i would probably like to see maloney given a go instead of radford,as he has had enough chances

All will be revealed soon! Wednesday afternoons are so exciting.

I've got Maloney on the bench. With sensible spelling that's a fair chance. Although it may be wiser to pair him with Cordoba and Moa with Radford I suppose. I'm not sure as I haven't seen Cordoba, but Moa and Maloney on the field together could be a bit too inexperienced.

Radford has had chances, but at the same time been forced into a corner. He's not now and never will be a loose forward, and IMO no longer even a wide-running back rower. At prop, however, I think he'd do the Dowes job, and do it pretty well.

I'd take enthusiastic inexperience over lazy experience any day (and also at prop

)

I'm not sure, I'd give the beneift of the doubt on that one. Fans have been crying out pretty much in unison for a number of specific selections throughout the season and he's taken no notice, I don't see why he would now. I'd be willing to give him credit for trying something different and to a certain extent admitting he's been wrong, it would be a big thing to do.

But I think both have to play TBH, it's just a case of when for which?

1.Tansey
2.Broughton
3.Yeaman
4.Hall
5.Raynor
6.Whiting
7.R.Horne
8.Cordoba
9.Berrigan
10.King
11.Burnett
12.Tickle
13.Hodgson

14.Houghton
15.Manu
16.Moa
17.Maloney

King?

www.sporthull.co.uk/rugby_league ... p?ID=13333 hall, calderwood in Broughton out Tansey in althoough probably on bench if paperwork arrives

www.sporthull.co.uk/rugby_league ... p?ID=13333 hall, calderwood in Broughton out Tansey in althoough probably on bench if paperwork arrives

Starting at prop?

bloody thorman!!!!

Well Hall in ahead of Broughton should do the lad's confidence with Agar the world of good. Hope he makes the 17 too.

Has not got the b****cks to drop him again, and to drop Radford.

Good to see Calderwood back in the squad.

Yeah i agree, was one of our best players before he got injured.

Agreed. Hopefully he'll brign back the enthusiasm he's shown this year and it will catch on.

How can you keep playing him???

So, Broughton stays, but isn't playing?
Thorman gets taken off, again, last week, but is still playing?
Tickle has a broken hand, but is still playing?

Also, I think someone needs to sit down with the RFL and do a streamlining exercise, how can it take much more than a few emails and 30 minutes to sort someones paperwork out?

I remember everyone on here calling for Calderwoods head at the beginning of the season? my how time flies when your having fun

If you can find a post of mine with such content I'll be impressed.

Indeed, I don't think anyone has done such, a fair few people (myself included) questioned his signing in the first place, but he has been one of the better performers in the side. (not really an accolade this season, granted)

Rubbish.

Again, I'm pleased to say, not me.

But you're right, I'd say the majority on here have seen the work he's put in and given credit where it's due. In the stands, however, I've lost count of the morons slating him for no reason during games.