Idiot? lol, maybe ambitious yes. I like whiting, hes played well many times, but think about it, under the new coach, wanting to build, where is whiting going to slot in??? Surely cannot be wing can it? And we have adequate cover in the loose forward position.

Think before you post.

Thankfully the faithful are a lot brighter than some on here, the faithful voted him as their player of the year as they clearly see his contribution..
Honestly it really is madness, I guarantee before the season starts we will have a thread saying get rid of him

Sam Tomkins

I will ask you again


Name me a better utility player in SL than Whiting!

He is a full back

Idiot, yes. Whiting can play just about any position to a good or very good standard. Players like that are invaluable in a salary capped sport. Only an idiot would suggest getting rid of him.

Kevin Sinfield.

Whiting out? He is no winger, but I far from want him out of the club.

Sharp was brilliant tonight.

and we will need at least one utility player and for me that should be whiting.

Are you piissed ?

He is a loose man, he would also cost a fortune compared to what we pay Whiting.

Do some people read? I said out of the two, i would have obst and whiting as backup.

I for one don't see a place for whiting next season unless their is injuries, I reckon they will be adequate players in their "CORRECT" positions from the new coach next season!

Whiting should be kept on imo, He's a good squad player and someone "Any team " should have . If Pearson's takeover could have happened a little earlier , I don't think Horne would be here next season either but we've got to play with the cards we have been dealt with for next year.
The rest, I and probably many among us wouldn't disagree .

Who has played 5/8 and on the Wing

Idiot.

I don't want utility though.

Kevin Sinfield is a utility player! Whiting has played out wide all season, does that make him a winger? no you said he's a utility player! where is whiting more effective? in the position HE HAS CURRENTLY NOT BEING PLAYED IN.

Kevin Sinfield is a UTILITY player, but his best position is a loose man

Granted, but we would have to get rid of most of the team to pay his wage

I know, I was just trying to be an annoying ****

Because a player can play well in other positions then their own does not mean they are a utility player. It means they're versatile. Sinfield is, and always will be, a 13.

You are definitely piissed....

feck it let us go the full hog bin Whiting and bring Benji Marshall in as utility

He's played only two positions his entire career.

Exactly mate, at least someone sees sense, a utility player comes handy during injuries, we want players playing in their position that they know, it's what makes a successful squad, no doubt about it! (BALANCED squad) would be the correct phase.

1. McKinnon
2. Briscoe
3. New centre
4. Yeaman
5. Sharp
6. Horne
7. Seymour
8. O'meley
9. Heremaia
10. New prop
11. Westerman
12. Whiting/New back rower
13. Tickle
14. Moa
15. O'carroll
16. Manu
17. Houghton

Briscoe, Lyne, Turner, Crooks, Nicklas, Ellis, Radford, Newton, Adlous, Green, Pearce and Cunningham to complete the squad.

It never worked, but to be fair you are up against a good clown on this thread

But he can play in different positions, so he's a utility. Whiting would not be a Utility player if we had just played him in his normal bloody position! But we couldn't because of injuries, and because of Agars clueless squad selections.