lineham looked poor today, shame really as I like the kid but imo didn't look fit and still has the defense issues,

Both him & westy haven't been missed.

Westerman managed to miss about 3 tackles in the lead up to Millingtons try, just not consistent enough to be a top player, him and Lineham are decent players, but not top ones and doubt they either will be, great business by Hull.

would have Briscoe back in a heartbeat, him and Tuli would be devastating.

I've also got first 3 but I've gone for Waky.

I wouldn't ever take Briscoe back. Lazy get just coasted while waiting for an NRL team to come forward. Let him fester at the bottom of the league. The only 2 players I'd take from Leeds are Lilley and Keinhorst. The rest are not even good enough for Rovers.

Briscoe was quick to get his bags packed and wave seeya to the faithful

, let the Herbert stew at the bottom in his loiners polyester shellsuit for me.

People remember a different Briscoe to me, his was excellent whilst at Hull, I never remember him coasting at Hull, his attitude and effort was top class. He decided to go Leeds to win things and in one season he has won more than his entire Hull career, so you can't blame him, hopefully this will change in the next few years and players like Tom won't want to leave Hull for the likes of Leeds. I would have Tom back in a heartbeat.

Amen. Tom's try scoring and defensive efforts gave me many happy memories.

Im not questioning the guys ability or his try scoring record etc,etc but lets not forget this is the same tom briscoe who couldnt wait to engineer a move away from us. Yes i know people move on to bigger and better things but the way he wanted out at every sniff at his door left a sour one in my mouth, for me he acted classless!

And yet you couldn't beat them

We beat teams around us, we have struggled against a few of the bottom clubs.

Carlos on the bench is an interesting option.

Tom Briscoe had an offer to go else where in 2011, but chose to stay at Hull at that point in time.

A fully fit Tom Briscoe would walk into any SL team and a fair few NRL teams.

To not want that type of playing your side is just plain childish.

We have Michaels & Naughton in his place, on almost the same cash, 2 for 1, so it was a loss at the time but I see it as a gain.

Maybe it was going to Leeds that hacked me off but to be fair i dont think we miss him at this moment in time. Im also a big believer in you dont go back, yes Briscoe's a decent player but i think there's plenty more about than him with the same capabilities. As for been childish i dont think i am, what if he re-signed for Hull then we had a poor season again, would he then decide Hull was not for him again????

Briscoe, at his time of leaving was one of the top 3 wingers in Super League (Hall and Charnley being the other 2). Having been at Hull for 6 seasons, we'd been in 2 losing CC finals and a best finish of 6th in SL. He came to the end of his contract and was free to leave. Its not like he was holding the club to ransom (ala Schofield) or walked out on us (ala Cooke).

If Hull had a poor season, any player could in theory say they didnt fancy it any more.

Have the rules changed again re dragging a player into touch? I thought they'd changed it to push only. Taylor just dragged a Waky player.

Some shocking officiating decisions in this game

Come on Wakey

Sneyd out according to HDM. Bollox.

Is tha bollox as in that's rubbish or bollox as in bloody hell no?

Mind games for Rovers cup final

Do you think you'll need him ?

I dont

Yes.