With respect, my objection to his signing hasn't been about his ability. Although I don't rate him much above average over the last few seasons.

The least of our worries.

for his first game, I thought he did well. Only just met his team mates today playing behind a beaten pack.
We couldnt ask for much more. Lets remember he is playing in an FC shirt, so give him our support.

Have to say he suprised me tonight, wasn't outstanding but wasn't bad either.

At least he seemed to have abit of aggression both in defence and whilst in attack when being tackled.

If I voted in the weekly MOM thread, McGoldrick would have been in my top three tonight. As would Horne.

Proving: a) I know nowt; b) Rlfans know nowt; c) Opinion is a great thing.

did ok i thought

Thought he showed how much we miss mckinnon.

We've not looked the same team since he went

Huge loss. With a new 1 and 6 we'll be a different side.

Didnt let us down but at same time not someone who will improve us

Not sure will get a new 1

Not if the 1 is mcgoldrick. Nowhere near the quality we need

Made his debut tonight

Might aswell give up if he's our number 1 next season

thought goldie played ok tonight, considering he only trained one day. organising, running the ball well, mopped up everything at back.

well done on your first game ryan

Spot on and he didnt even train with the side before he played, said in the interview mwt most of the players on the bus down.

Well done to fit in, 1 forward pass but otherwse was steady in the game, will get better with training.

I thought goldie played well tonight he ran the ball in hard and showed aggression considering he only trained one day.

Did better than I expected given that he hasn't trained with us. Will be interesting to see if he gets any better once he has.

I hope so like i said he ran the ball well and showed aggression, just hope he gets better with time with us considering he aint trained with us yet.

So all the doom and gloom as lifted after just 1 appearance . I'm not going again , I'm not renewing my pass etc just days ago . Just shows how some are so fickle on here . Ok he's no world beater but id take him as cover next season , but no way was he has bad as some made out this week .

The guy's average, the fact Cas don't want him is not a good sign.

Same applies to Jamie Ellis then?

cas don't want him before he's even played for them?

I think money comes into it also.. The saving they've made by 'swapping' is ridiculous!!

He's certainly come a long way since Blue Peter

Personally, I never said I'd stop going. I said I didn't want him here, and I still don't. I don't have a say in the matter, though.