I didn't think there was alot in it tbh, he made contact with Ogre but Ogre wasn't getting anywhere near Roby. If it was a player then it may have been chalked off but the ref is classed as part of the field so it's irrelevant, Ganson had to give it.

It was lost by foster and never touched Horne's hands so our srum or advantage a TRY

Rubbish, of course he touched it.

I suggest you watch it again not with his hand ,Foster lost it so knock on by him .
Our scrum.

the way i saw it was Foster was in the act of catching the ball and Horne knocked it from his grasp,right decision for mine. The washbrook one i think he got wrong,he went to catch the ball,not tackle the player,he had as much right to penalise the saints player as washbrook.

The ball WAS in contact with Foster's hand when Horne knocked it on so the decision was right.

You lot need to stop clutching at straws.

I've watched it plenty of times thanks.

So you are saying that Horne didn't even touch the ball? How exactly did the ball suddely change direction then?

Sorry Besty watched it a few times now and Foster never had control of the ball and the ball was away from his hand before Horne touched it.

Totally agree with the Washbrook one he had his on the ball all the time...

Regardless of what people think about the knock on, that decision was Thaler's so Ganson can't be blamed.

Saints had two fine passes given as forward, Meli's and Roby's.

Foster clearly knocks on as does Horne, should've been Hull ball.

As for the penalty, crazy decision. Washbrook's arms indicate that without a doubt he was challenging for the ball.

And if you listen clearly a point made by Ganson himself too the Hull players

I said not with his hands ,Foster lost it touches Horne then thats a knock on .
Simple

I think the fact washy never took his eyes of the ball aswell as his arms clearly indicates he was challenging for the ball..

Of course he touched it with his hand, Foster was in the process of gathering the ball and the ball was in contact with his hand when Horne knocked it forward.

The decision was correct.

I can't believe you lot are moaning so much with the number of incorrect decisions that went your way, including the forward pass you got away with in the try that won you a point, get over it.

wrong he had lost contact before horne touched it

There was no visible seperation of the ball and Fosters hand,if ther ehad of been then the try would of stood

no it would have been called back for the second knock on by horne..

Hull got the ball back straight away anyway, Shenton was bundled into touch about five seconds after the scrum.

15m further down the pitch

That was the one decision that bothered me, the rest I thought was about right.

we had 9 1st teamers out injured, and we where still bloody unlucky not to win! so stop spitting ya dummies out, god help ya when we put our strongest side out against you.

Like in the two matches last year eh?

9 first teamers, really? I think you are including the youngsters too.

We had four out.