Not really no. I think we need to get someone with experience of RL to a high level to get our club back on the right track. I also think we need to get rid of the whole backroom staff as well but doubt it will happen.

I would rather Webbo given the job before Edwards. He has some experience coaching RL but still not the right man for the job either.

Is he still at a club side? Bath or Wasps?

Wed never get him but he would be a great coach in the sl.

Been away from RL for far too long. We don't need someone doing on the job learning.

I would'nt have thought a man with his expierience in League, would be a learner and his coaching at a very high level in union, hardly makes him a novice. Combine the two and maybe he would do good job for someone

In what way has he got vast experience in rugby league

Think you missed the hint of sarcasm to his post.

think he cud do a job with his playing experience and also coaching at top level in union he wud be gud. Also the people who are sayin no, who else is there that wud changd things and who wud want to come.

There are always people available, money has a habit of changing peoples allegiances.

Shaun Edwards is a rugby league legend and could walk into any coaching job in Super League.
The guy has years and years of league experience - it's in his veins. I'd love to see him back in our game. Don't let the fact that he coaches on the dark side fool you.
But would he ever be the right coach for us? - No. Besides, we couldn't afford him.

why wouldnt he be the right coach for us if he could walk into any team?

Lets give the job to Offiah, ffs people it is the future of our club we are talking about and I for one do not what an untested coach given the chance to get his feet. We have done that and look at the mess we are currently in.

We couldn't afford him.

I don't see how he's untested. He's been working at the very top level in RU for many years. He'd make a fine SL coach.

World of difference between coaching RL and RU.

Edwards and Offiah cant be compared, firstly Edwards is currently coaching at national level. In their playing days Edwards was a complete general on and off the field, Offiah put his head back and ran like Forest Gump. Where is Offiah's credentials for coaching a SL club

Where are Edwards???

I would agree if we were talking about Clive Woodward or Martin Johnson. However, I don't suppose there's too much Edwards doesn't know about RL, what with him having played the odd game.

Andy Farrell maybe ? if we are talking about the 'dark side' ?

The game has changed a hell of a lot over the last 10 years that he has been out of it. He just is not someone who we can afford to take a risk on, he may well turn out to be a great coach but I would much rather we got someone with a good track record in RL than someone who would be classed as a gamble.

We ought to test Huddersfield regarding Brown ££££££££££££

He is a born leader who is currently coaching at national level, when he played he led from on the field and off. He could have played at 1,2,5,6,7,9 in any team of that time he was that good. Offiah was very good at the one job he could do

Been away from league for too long.The game has changed since he was last involved.

Andy Farrell, on the condition he brings his son, a cracking kicker and HB.....

He's also a pioneer of coaching techniques.

He'll still be studying rl, he adopts some tactics in ru.

But like Paul says we can't afford him.

Imo Edwards has too much of an ego for our club, it's obvious we don't employ people with the ability to make decisions of their own without interference from elsewhere.