They're all poor, Doc included. They should be approaching the commentary as if they were explaining what was happening to a blind friend at the game because that's basically what their job is.

Good close see-saw game. Thought we just about shaded it. Good confidence for the final try and great effort to drag the Hudds player into touch to win it.

Much needed win and didnt play particularly well, Thought Heremaia and watts did well and seymour was ok but by himself alot of time just messed up for a try

the reason gollum cant string a sentence together is because he is thinking how he can slip his new long word in from his dictionary.
he even called us hull k.r today in his commentary,..says it all !!

Good game of RL to watch, was end to end stuff that could have gone either way. However I do feel a better side would have punished both Hull and Hudds for some poor errors during the game.

I am very pleased that the players heads didn't drop when we went behind, and I am even more pleased that we now head in to a very difficult part of the season (playing away at Headingley, Catalan and Craven Park) with a much needed win under out belts.

Great win for us. Much needed. We played some really great stuff in the game, looking to ship it out and support more than we have in recent weeks.

The Heremaia/Houghton partnership can become very good indeed.

Very pleased with the win!!
Great try by Heremaia to spark a bit of life back into us. I think the whole stadium must have fallen for that dummy. I was watching Danny Tickle running back inside and wondering why he didn't have the ball.

Looks like I should let him off if he's done his bicep.

Funny reading this getting back from the game, we had a bad spell about half way through the second half but overall played some good rugby, the defence was pretty good. I was meh about the proposed signing of Brough but he was superb today and really caused us some problems.

Gentle said they sent the message out to not pass the ball

It was more the ones that went to ground I noticed rather than him stop passing it. Understandable now though.

How could anyone feel like that about the chance to sign the best English 7 in the league? The blokes class, he would walk into any team in the league barring Catalans perhaps.

back to winning ways and an important 2 points, nice to beat giants finally at home with a decent squad as some of their fans were a little too cocky after beating us on easter monday and in the chalenge cup when our squad was down to its bones!

Overall good show from the lads, played to the 80 minutes for a change and came up with some sucker punches to win the game.

Brough's kicking game is outstanding.

Happy with the outcome but thought we lacked any urgency for large parts of the game. Tickle & Manu were both very poor, I know Tickle got injured but even before then.
We seem to lack any execution skills, poor runners meant players like Seymour & Westerman got caught with the ball far too often (they then get slagged off). The amount of times a player has to reach out to take a pass or even check his run is shocking.
We could have the best organising scrum half in the league (I think we've got one of them) but when players are unable to execute the basics of catch & pass then any structure just falls down, we then resort to panic plays which lead to rushed options at the end of the set and ultimately turning the ball over poorly.

On a brighter note, Heremaia looks very good and Watts did well also. Thought Pitts was excellent in defence against a massive pack.

I was overseas when he first played for us so never saw him, he just seemed like a kicker whenever I saw him on sky. Changed my mind today! How old is he ?

The back to 1 call when the hudds player kicked it into the back of the Hull player was farcical

Add in the Hudds player running behind his teammates and the second penalty for interference IMO just being a fumble by the Hudds player and it really was ridiculous.

And our player tackling their player and he calling all on, when in reality it was a loose carry.

29 mate.

It really is quite astonishing that with how many errors we've just listed between us from one passage of play, not one of them was picked up by the officials and a try was given. It should be a cause of embarassment to the RFL.

The standard of refereeing is shocking across the board in our league. Refs should not have as many game changing moments as they do in SL.

child was rubbish today. Didn't keep the teams apart and allowed far too much messing about in the ruck

He's the worst ref in SL. He just doesn't control games.