Preventing a try scoring opportunity.

So the high tackle wouldn't be the reason for the sin bin then. I've never seen a sin bin for a stand alone high tackle.

It's no different to me than fighting, why should it not be given 10 minutes? Either way it wasn't bad enough for a red.

I'm not saying it shouldn't be a sin bin I'm just saying it never happens. It's only ever just a penalty or a red card. Can ever recall somebody getting a sin bin for a high tackle?

I don't recall any but not sure it would be something I would remember. Usually Ganson gives reds, to our players!

Did you see the program on TV a few years back, behind the scenes in Rugby League, Can't remember the exact title.

In that Ganson turned up to ref a match and gave clear instructions to the linesmen not to signal and to let him make the decisions. What a joke he is and a primadonna.

I wouldn't mind him making all the decisions, if he got them right.

I'm not saying it would have been a game changer, we were awful, but it needs looking into and a ban put in place. If that had have been a tackle on a Leeds player, or even us on KR yesterday I believe it would have been a red card for sure.

No different to Manu on Cockayne in the 2010 playoff game

Penalty and move on

anyone wishing a player injured is the true scum of our game, unfortunately a loss has seen a few drag themselves out of the gutter and tarnish your club. I could only hope it was a few post match beers talking and not meant as posted. Otherwise you really need a bang on head and go and support another game this one doesn't need you.

Fwiw I wouldn't have complained if he'd took a binning, very careless tackle bhut I've seen worse go on report.

That got put on report and wasn't a high tackle,



Just watched it again though. and will watch it again and again. Thanks its making me feel much better

So it was a high tackle then

Hull fans in desperate attempt to find an excuse for a heavy defeat shocker.
Burns should have walked ?
do me a favour.

When was a 13pt defeat heavy?

Wish you would do us all a favour.

No

read the rules

Most people up East Hull are taking the score sheet to a guy and he's manipulating it to read 10 - 2300

Just a pity they cant cash in a score sheet.

I see he's been charged and rightly so.

Good. He's a thug

Graeme Horne v Hull FC on 29/3/2013.

Are you concussed?

Incorrect. He got sin binned for a penalisable offence while under a team warning. The fact that it was a high tackle was incidental.

So.if he hadn't made the high tackle he would have still been sin binned?

So it wasn't a high tackle in some peoples minds (dobbins).. Just a quick question,

If burns was able to tackle him, why did he go for the neck/head area? Was it a deliberate attempt to hurt crookes or did he his head was a pie that's why he went all out for it?

Where have you seen this? Not on RFL disciplinary web page.

www.bbc.co.uk/sport/0/rugby-league/22009165 dont see any benefit as he will be missing due to injury, if he was sent off in the game, maybe then we may had, but the way we played i doubt we would've beaten 12 men for the rest of the match!

www.bbc.co.uk/sport/0/rugby-league/22009165 dont see any benefit as he will be missing due to injury, if he was sent off in the game, maybe then we may had, but the way we played i doubt we would've beaten 12 men for the rest of the match!

Only if it had been a penalisable(?) offence in the tackle. The team was on a warning so next penalty was a yellow

And the offence committed was a high tackle. Therefore, Horne was sin binned for a high tackle .Ipso Facto

when will people learn, never argue with idiots, they bring you down to their level and then beat you with expereince.