Big blow to lose him and what I don't understand is why we can't retain him? Is it simply wanting to win trophies? If we want to be successful we have to keep our best players. You won't see Hall or Charnley leaving.

If tomkins ends up going to the NRL next season i cant see wigan winning anything!

Look at the end of last season when they lost him in the play offs, they were nowhere near a threat when he was in the squad. Could be another manu scenario!

Be really dissapointed if he goes to another SL club having stated his desire to play in the NRL

Briscoe will go wherever the money is, as we all would. He's a good player, he's not a one man team.

So why not resign for fc as our offer was reported to be better than what he was offered from aus

win bonus?
reported by whom?

where would you go in his shoes, FC or Wigan?

Was mentioned by fc when they offered him the new contract

If tomkins stays-wigan
If tomkins goes-fc

At his age? I'd genuinely stay at FC for another couple of seasons and see if what we're trying to build here comes to fruition. It's not like we're offering peanuts or it's his last chance to win trophies etc.

With Hock, Mossop, Richards, Tomkins leaving Wigan, and potentially Wane as coach too, surely that would be a risk him going to Wigan with a lot of uncertainty about how the team will manage with those losses.

I would not be happy if after all of this he leaves Hull to move 2 hours West.

Me neither. I would lose at lot of repsect for him if he does. Although he's mostly kept his own council about this he seems to have allowed stories that's he's going to Aus prosper and most of us have been understanding of this. But to go to a SL rival would be a kick in the teeth for me.

If Briscoe goes to wigan it will be a kick in the teeth for FC as he's always said he would be going to AUS.
Didnt he say that he'd stay with us if he couldn't get an offer in AUS??

Good player but not the world beater some say he is on here...id sooner have players who want to take this team forward and challenge...he had messed us about so bye Tom.

Yes I agree. He's had long enough to make his mind up and as he shows no sign of accepting our offer its time we made a decision and moved on.

If he wants to take his time and club are happy to wait fair enough. He doesn't owe us anything and this next contract may be the one that makes him for life.
I'm assuming it's somewhere in the 200k area n if it's 3/4yrs why wouldn't you weight it up. Cos we don't know what's happening doesn't mean the clube doesn't

If he wants to take his time and club are happy to wait fair enough. He doesn't owe us anything and this next contract may be the one that makes him for life.
I'm assuming it's somewhere in the 200k area n if it's 3/4yrs why wouldn't you weight it up. Cos we don't know what's happening doesn't mean the club doesn't.
Best I know of it he's still waiting on oz move.

"Take his time"? He's had months, it's clear that he is leaving.

Maybe the club already know and for whatever reason are keeping it quiet, otherwise I'm disappointed that Briscoe hasn't been more upfront.

The more I see Lineham , The less I think about Briscoe staying .

Agree with this

after listening to mcrea tonight, i think its nailed on briscoe and tickle will leave at the end of the season

Will be gutted in a way when he goes. Hard to replace and hard to take him going to another English club rather than the nrl.
That said he may be be joining a Wigan club who are shedding quality players.
I'm sure the club will reinvest his and tickles salary back into the squad.

Other than the dropped kick off I thought he was excellent last night. He's also been moving around the field a lot more than he used to. Will be a big loss for us

What did his try in the corner get ruled out for last night?

roby being useless

Yes he played well and there is no doubting he is a quality player but if he doesn't want to stay then so be it. He hasn't been Mr consistent for me this season.
I personally don't see it as a big loss as we have lineham and crookes who are imo just as dynamic.
We also then don't have a huge chunk of our salary cup on the wing enabling us to strengthen in other areas.

I can't believe you really think this! If I was a FC fan I would not want the club to be held to ransom by Briscoe, let him go. He stopped developing as a player a couple of seasons ago. You have better wingers than him at the club. He is strong and looks good with ball in hand, but his defence is questionable at times.