Fat boy is a joke - as for criteria I think we could all list some possibilities.

I don't believe Ganson was actually going to do anything at the time, he seemed to miss it or ignore it. It was the intervention of the touch judge that brought a penalty.

I don't think he was going to bin Horne until it was pointed out to him that he had given a team warning.

He actually looked at the big screen to see who to bin for that one.

Not a red for me, should have got 10 mins though.

When was the last time you saw a player get sin-binned for a high tackle? I literally can't ever remember it happening. It's always just a penalty or a red card.

Correct - calling for 10 mins is just a nothing call.

will only bin after a few high shots, although this has now been replaced by the ref doing gangnam style for a team warning

Preventing a try scoring opportunity.

So the high tackle wouldn't be the reason for the sin bin then. I've never seen a sin bin for a stand alone high tackle.

It's no different to me than fighting, why should it not be given 10 minutes? Either way it wasn't bad enough for a red.

I'm not saying it shouldn't be a sin bin I'm just saying it never happens. It's only ever just a penalty or a red card. Can ever recall somebody getting a sin bin for a high tackle?

I don't recall any but not sure it would be something I would remember. Usually Ganson gives reds, to our players!

Did you see the program on TV a few years back, behind the scenes in Rugby League, Can't remember the exact title.

In that Ganson turned up to ref a match and gave clear instructions to the linesmen not to signal and to let him make the decisions. What a joke he is and a primadonna.

I wouldn't mind him making all the decisions, if he got them right.

I'm not saying it would have been a game changer, we were awful, but it needs looking into and a ban put in place. If that had have been a tackle on a Leeds player, or even us on KR yesterday I believe it would have been a red card for sure.

No different to Manu on Cockayne in the 2010 playoff game

Penalty and move on

anyone wishing a player injured is the true scum of our game, unfortunately a loss has seen a few drag themselves out of the gutter and tarnish your club. I could only hope it was a few post match beers talking and not meant as posted. Otherwise you really need a bang on head and go and support another game this one doesn't need you.

Fwiw I wouldn't have complained if he'd took a binning, very careless tackle bhut I've seen worse go on report.

That got put on report and wasn't a high tackle,



Just watched it again though. and will watch it again and again. Thanks its making me feel much better

So it was a high tackle then

Hull fans in desperate attempt to find an excuse for a heavy defeat shocker.
Burns should have walked ?
do me a favour.

When was a 13pt defeat heavy?

Wish you would do us all a favour.

No

read the rules

Most people up East Hull are taking the score sheet to a guy and he's manipulating it to read 10 - 2300

Just a pity they cant cash in a score sheet.

I see he's been charged and rightly so.

Good. He's a thug

Graeme Horne v Hull FC on 29/3/2013.

Are you concussed?