still do a job

Think looking I didn't appreciate the job raynor did for the team and would take him anyday over sharp

so, a convicted, violent fraudster....... no thanks.

I did - always rated him very highly as a player. Injuries, and more importantly multiple criminal convictions, mean "no thanks", though.

ah van and raynor are both much better than sharp. hull have a vv strong pack but i think elima would be in your squad one way or another. Who are the props as well for you guys, as i would have thought scruton would be in your squad.

And anyone who wants phelps over kearney is on a different planet

I wouldn't have him in front of O'Meley or Moa,but would put him before Radford and Dowes.Saying that,Dowes is playing as good as ever at the moment.

Imagine we'll line up like this :

Kearney
Raynor
Whitehead
Ah Van
Crookes
Herbert
Jeffries
Lynch
Diskin
Kopzcak
Elima
Sibbit
Langley

Addy/O'Brien
Donaldson
Scruton (if fit)/ Olbison
Burgess

This could well be the game that decides who finishes in 8th. Hope it's a good one and have a safe journey over!

Obviously biased, but to say you wouldn't take Langley or Elima is a bit stupid imo.

Langley is one of the best defenders in Super League, a natural leader and Bradford are a better side with him on the field. If any of you watched Saints v Bulls then you'll know what Elima offers - he was excellent in that game. I Think oyu do have a good backrow, and Fitzgibbon is an excellent player, but it comes close with Manu, and I think Langers & Elima are better players than Westerman & Tickle. All opinion obviously, and we'll get to see them up against each other this sunday!

I would not take Langley but would have Elima coming off the bench, would taken Diskin too and Lynch.

For kids to get into away ground free with their pass do you just use the pass on the day or do you have to exchange voucher for a ticket at the office?

Gleeson not back - still ill according to Agar on RH.

1.whiting
2.lyne
3.turner
4.yeamen
5.briscoe
6.horne
7.obst
8.omeley
9.houghton
10.radders
11.tickle
12.manu
13.fitzgibbon
subs
14.moa
15.lauaki
16.dowes
17.westerman

For us Westerman would be better as we lack creativity as it is and Elima and Langley would not add to this.

i would fear for us with lyne on the wing against the likes of ah van, whitehead(if he plays centre), evans or raynor, 4 big players up against a lightweight winger, just a shame gleeson or phelps won't make it

sick of hull now his mate's injured?

evans?, sharp isnt any bigger but i agree that i think the right wing is a bit of a problem

Hope Lynn does not play this week, rather have Sharp back.

Whilst I agree that at the moment Sharp is the better of the two players, we can't keep putting Lyne is for one game then drop him the next he needs a run of games either for us or a Championship club to get him use to playing at a better level and help his confidence grow.

He needs to persevere with one of lynne or sharp

At 25 sharp should be the finished article but he's a long way off IMO

Think he started the game late, also had he every worked with a really good coach?

Good going foward, if he had a good coach like Nathan Brown he could help him with his faults and make him into an excellent winger.

who's evans? assume you mean james evans who left us 2 or 3 years ago?

I agree and I would go with Sharp, makes more yardage and is a better finisher.

He's fecked at Hull then if he needs a decent coach

sharp should play been made a fall guy long enough lynne is not good enough yet simple really