Pish take and more Pish take for sure. I am absolutely Gob-smacked to say the least. What a fecking farce. You just wait until it involves a Hull player: Hame or O'Meley 3 matches or more.

Disciplinary system a complete farce, how can you be guilty one day, and not guilty the next? is it a different panel for the appeal,?

It could well be, I know in most disciplinary cases in the work place it is usually a different person who hears the appeals, so I would suspect this could be the same

What a joke, that's twice in 2 weeks someone has been banned one day and the lifted the next, the RFL are a joke!

Should we start a petition?

Didn't it hapen to one of our players last season? Or maybe the ban was shortened. Personally I'd do away with the appeals. The player and club have the opportunity to put their case forward at the hearing and that should be enough. In fact I'd go to fixed penalties, no hearing. Serve your punishment. Current way of doing things is no disincentive to anyone

Fully agree, I don't understand why they meet one day and appeal the next. Just have the hearing, listen to what the player/club have to say and then make a decision, end of.

I mean they found Carvell guilty, then he appealed so they said ok then you're not guilty

Im wondering the same thing. RFL are a sham.

Following this weekends fixtures it is now apparent that forearm smashes, late high tackles and punches all carry the penalty of a slap on the wrist and no ban. It will be interesting to see how similar incidents are treated in the weeks to come. To find Carvell guilty of a grade C offence which carries 2 - 3 weeks suspension - fine him £300 then rescind the one match ban makes no sense to me

I haven't seen the judgements on either but it seems from news reports and other summaries that the RFL like making themselves look stupid.

The fact is they have still found him guilty and the fine stands. This makes it even more of a mockery.

No surprise there then