Told from a reliable source (and i dont often post this stuff) that Skinny is going home. Hall or Motu for FB. I'd personally have Briscoe in front of Hall for the centre shirt but its nice to have the options.

If we lose Byrne for the season we really have to find a utility replacement, as only Hall can cover the FB slot.

Not ready imo.....whole different ball game there and think he would get exposed a bit...will make a cracking centre but lets build him up slowly to it..he may not even end up there...possible replacement for 1 of our wingers when they leave?

Why not an out and out full back and let motu be the utility?

I haven't seen Briscoe actually play at centre, which is why at the moment I'd prefer Hall there. I know he has the necessary skills and I haven't had a chance to form an opinion on whether Briscoe does.

Hall instead of Briscoe for me....if its the other way round...can see Hall going tbh.

I'm not having that conversation again.

But if crocker does come, get briscoe at right centre and let crocks help him out.

Hall at right centre if he isnt covering F/B.

He's shakier than briscoe!!!

Not to mention a complete lightweight.

Did you not see him come on in the cup final last year?

Ive seen him play there a few times and have been massively impressed with him as i am with his wing play. Going to be a huge star for us wherever he plays.

As has also been said, if Crocker comes (and im now 99% he will) Hall could play outside of him and be protected a bit more defensively.

One good run and he lost the ball then went off......same can be said of Hall with Crocker defending.

Barely. We were right up at the top of the stadium.



I'd prefer a few more performances to base an opinion on TBH. I'm aware that plenty of folk rate him but I just prefer to form my own opinions.

I don't doubt that he'll be a star for us, just remains to be seen in what position.

We looked a hell of a lot better as a side we he came on for G horne. Its also harsh knocking him for losing the ball, he broke his ankle!!

Either centre or winger he will be a star, maybe it should be up to him to decide were he feels most natural. If he wants to be a centre i don't see much point in keeping him out on the wing for much longer.

Guess we'll see. Its nice to have the quality of players that we do though.

I agree about Horne but Hall should have been there as well.

But he's getting game time playing on the wing.

Well Halls getting the chance to show what he can do now, and looked very good on Friday. Lets hope he makes himself un-droppable.

It was second half in front of the east stand, near the start of the first half, before cats scored there try!

does agar think that tho?

Who cares!

Agar loves him. I think he probably does, but wants to bring him on gently so as not to break him a la poor Tommy Lee.

Question is - if pressure of injuries dictates, will Agar risk him in the centres prematurely?

your not wrong there.

he may have to.

Just watched it again and could easilty gone himself

For me the final pass was forward too !