clearly not, our next coach needs to be someone who has won something as a creative player.

On that point who would you say are the top 3 coaches in both England and the nrl and which position did the play during playing days ?

You mean like Tony Smith, Brian McDermott, Shaun Wane, Wayne Bennett and Tim Sheens?

all taken on teams with proven creative players, we either sign one, or nurture one, but they need someone to learn from.

So our next coach [idoesn't[/i necessarily needs to be "someone who has won something as a creative player"?

my belief is it does, or a proven coach.

my opinion is no more or less valid just because you don't agree with it.

Where did I say it wasn't? I was merely questioning your opinion by pointing out that success teams don't necessarily have to have a coach who was a creative player.

but you can't have neither, as we have proven for the last 5 years!

Starting at 7 today for Donny

Wattsy starting as well as Colborn, HT Donny losing 2-8

Just seen a comment by a Donny fan who has been to the game" why did we pick miller, clearly not intrested" that's dissapointing if true he should have been busting a gut to show radders that he is wrong to drop him!!

He was not very good , poor kicking game , poor passing game & didn't seem interested.

poor, I would have expected better from him

If he wants to get back in our first team he will not get anywhere with that attitude, i thought he would do anything he could to try and prove Radford wrong but seems that is not the case at the moment

He was substituted , think that sums it up !

How longs he he got left on his contract wouldn't he be better just cut your losses and pay him off

It's not his attitude, it's his ability

be surprised if he gets back in.our halfback options are getting worse.

Bang on jake.

Disappointing if it's true. I thought maybe Horne's poor performance last night may have spurred Miller on to put in a good shift.

wonder whether someone who has never played but been a studier of the game would work, someone similar to mourinho in football. Trouble with rugby people is 90% of them are thick. Just because you've won stuff as a player under the best coaches doesn't mean you'll be any good. Creative players generally struggle to tell others how they do it as it's usually a natural ability and too easy for them . In most sports the true greats make poor coaches.

Disappointed if he really hasn't put a shift in. I've been a fan since he arrived and want him to do well. If he's not d, he might just be added to the list of failed scrum half candidates

Heard tonight that he's got an offer on the table from Aus, made possible by Peter Gentle.

Also heard that Sneyd is very close to agreeing a deal with us.

that would be great news on both points

Ironic that Anthony Thackeray should be lining up against Miller eh. Wonder how smug he felt last night after such a dominant display, scoring a couple of times to boot (scored 5 the other week!). See some Dewsbury fans moaning anout Millers attitude, they will of course have expected him to be a 'fairly decent' player, so obviously put his performance down to attitude, not realising (and why would they) that he's simply a poor player.

Thackeray was a local lad on peanuts, never given a chance whilst we were happy to about with various half back combos pulling players like Berrigan and Washy out of position on a regular basis. Not saying he'd have made it with us but food for thought, especially in relation to salarys being earnt/cap etc.

PS - Who was the poor sod who normally plays 7 for Donny?! Wonder what Cooke will do now Miller becomes his 'problem'?