totally unfair criticism aimed at some of the players tonite, some of those idiots/to55ers who rang in humberside criticising the likes of calderwood, tommy lee etc should go and take a runnin jump off a cliff

top of the league and so called fans criticising players

Apart from touching a ball that was destine for the touch line ,I Carnot think of much else to criticize him for.

i don't even think Tommy Lee knocked on, progress is finally being made

Don't quite understand your dig! I have never questioned Marks signing, in fact I was more than happy, however, I don't think he deserves his place ahead of Raynor and Briscoe. What the hell that has to do with our cowardly cousins across the channel?

think the kids done well the past 2 weeks

It'll never end, some people just don't have a clue what's what.

he is much better at 2nd row, he doesn't think quickly enough when he's been at halfback or hooker

apart from his try against celtic, calderwood hasn't really had a sniff on the wing, but he does make it up in defence, granted he doesn't fill me with confidence under the high ball, but thought he took the correct option tonight, palming the ball dead for a drop out, if he caught it on the full, he could have been dragged into touch, giving hudds a better attacking option from a scrum

I stopped listening to this idiot infested station ages ago.
"ey ricy , Im gonna call up umbersid and say the word f*ck.

dead right, im beginning to think some fans just get pi55ed up then decide to slag players off because theyve been slagged off in the past whether its when playin for hull or even another club. so what if calderwood was a complete tool at leeds, i'll support the bloke cos he now plays for us and if it means the team doing well with the likes of tommy & calders then thats fine by me.

if we manage to get crocker over with luauki also to come plus players like whiting, raynor, tony and washy etc then we've a great chance of racking up a decent year.

COME ON U ULLLAARRR!!

Spot on!

Damn right, WHEN (not if) we get Lauaki and Crocker, we will be fearsome.

You and I should meet for a chat to discuss the location of that wonderful flag pole

ONIONS

What is all this about, we have the two best wingers in the country and the biggest prospect ever in the same positon. Ignore the original thread and enjoy.

says it all

Defensively great second half, tracking back twice if i recall to tackle man and ball, just one criticism, that all wingers are coming in for at the moment, he's either in front of or level with the centre, so not running on to the pass, otherwise sound for me.

good game i thought and hasnt done alot wrong,he doesnt get any ball

Good defensively but I don't believe with our style of play that we'll ever get the best out of him. Our game plan isn't expansive enough to exploit his running abilities and our kicking game isn't good enough to utilise his pace. We also ask our back 3 to take the ball in for the first 2 or 3 tackles and this isn't a strong area for him meaning we don't get the best platform early in the tackle count. A quick look at the stats for the 1st 3 games is quite telling

[url=http://www.superleague.co.uk/statistics_player.php?hs1=2009&hp1=3197&hs2=2009&hp2=266&stat=tries&season=2009Here[/url

We have 100%, wa cannot ask for any-more...I am sure as the weather improves and the pitches get quicker Calderwood will delight...Come on u ullllllllllllllla

Calderwood,Raynor,Briscoe.
Not bad options in all fairness.Personaly I think Calderwood will do o.k. for us as the season progresses.
All we need now is to start using the wings.

Are you talking attack or defence?

Both

Calderwood needs a decent centre playing alongside him. G Horne is solid but will never make a centre.
Maybe if Whiting plays centre Calderwood will see a decent pass?