Best bit on the red button forum...interview with Tomkins on the verge of tears, but all you can hear are the Hull lads belting out old faithful in the changing rooms

Think the whole thing is really good - BBC coverage gets criticism but Mark Chapman, Dave Woods, John Kear, Brian Noble and particularly Jon Wilkin are far better than Sky's team IMO. Not keen on Robbie Paul, Jonathan Davies or Jamie Peacock but overall I thought BBC did a great job, as they did last year. Really hope Wilkin gets a gig with Sky when he hangs his boots up - really articulate and insightful.

Suggested he had champagne in his eyes

St Helens
Catalans
Wigan
Warrington
Catalans
Castleford
Leeds
Wigan

That is some record.

Totally agree. Dave woods is a great rl commentator. Really captures the moment. Enjoyed watching cup games far more than sky .Met Mark Chapman once over 10yrs ago and he said then one of his greatest sportent events was Cardiff 05. Comes across in his presenting how much he enjoys being around rugby league

chapman is a Hull fan from his student days I think (along with durham). peacock just talks in soundbites. It's like he has prepared everything he's going to say beforehand.

Although I don't want to, I actually like john wilkin and he obviously has a lot of respect for a lot of the Hull palyers

Jonathan "just watch " Davies really gets on my tits.

I thought those small bottles were beer tbh, he did get sprayed in the eyes though

He was the one that gave big credit to CT for making the tackle that meant Clubb lost control - and in real time that's how I saw it, a little pressure on the ball as per every tackle in SL and Clubb didn't have control of the ball sufficiently. Child was for once correct.

Shame the rest of the bbc are not like them absolutely no mention on any of the sports bulletins this morning on BBC news, they mentioned the boxing, women's rugby union and the football and the final was broadcast on BBC 1what does that tell us.

Must say I noticed that, quite ridiculous!

Read Stuart Cummings column in this weeks League Weekly. Mcillorums punch was in retaliation to the one thrown by Ellis. Seems that everybody missed that one.

In the initail tackle,Mcllorum headbutts Ellis,he retaliates,then Mcllorum throws another punch.
Seems everybody missed that????

If you want to class that as a deliberate head butt then you need to take up knitting. Happens probably about 10 times a game in tackles. Did you see Ellis and MM keep on at each other afterwards? No. That's because they both recognised it for what it was. Hull won,back to back cup triumphs,congrats.No disrespect intended,just pointing out what was written by a well respected former official,in response to what the Loiner said.

The same former official that ranted on about clubbs no try yet hardly mentioned the foot in touch leading up to Burgess' try?

Stuart Cummings is many things, well respected is not one of them!

Congratulations from a Cas fan.

Great team performance and the fans were brilliant.

Think that performance makes you favourites for the grand final now.

Watch it again.without the chip on your shoulder.it was a full on deliberate head butt.Ellis re-acted,I cant remember him reacting like that since he has been at the club.So Cummins was wrong and you,the initial penalty should of gone to Hull

Robbie Paul is just cringe, cant string a sentence together and gets things wrong, he always refers to the game been over 90 mins to!!!

You mean when Ellis was on his back, open fist, more of a push than a punch

I'm just waiting for the day when he is running round the pitch getting in the way of players' warm ups and someone flattens him.

That would be funny

You'd think with Robbie Paul being an ex player that he'd know the last thing the players want while getting ready for a game in him creeping round them in the warm up & changing rooms.

Thanks, but with which bookmaker please?