At the time it was the right decisions on both imho

I'd sooner have Hall's dad.

HDM Headline - Super Hall shows FC what they are missing - sums it up for me - never good enough but yesterday played really well - but if we are missing him sorry we are in a very bad place.

hall did the damage to upset all us fc fans thou!!! just realy hurts i hate it when kr beat us rant over lol

both good players, but not great players!

none of leeds, saints, wigan and warrington came sniffing when they were available!

Hall is a gifted player at times gash at other times,we gave him enough time but he never did it enough at fc, still not a cert to start at the dobbins when there have a full team, no mistake imo

Hall doesn't get in our 1st 17. Had a good game yesterday and is great as a fill in player, nothing more. Hodgson has improved year on year, future captain without a doubt.

Hodgson decided to opt for Rovers days after picking up your U20's POTY award. Agar never wanted him to leave and he was fuming that Hodgson had opted to join us.

Who would yo pick at right centre then, please dont say Arundel over Hall

Yeah, that's what happened.

Forget josh Hodgson and Craig hall, I'm more gutted about us letting Danny brough leave he's head and shoulders above these two by a country mile

Journeyman

He couldnt hold down the 9 shirt in our 20's ,Jack Iley kept him out

Who brough?

hodgson always played 13/looseman whenever i saw the u20s

one good game against us doesn't mean we should have kept him. he was at fault in defence in the 2 derby games we won last season. didn't hear anyone say we should have kept him then

Josh Hodgson is an England/ GB player before too long I really do think. He's a real good player.

If you are glad you didn't keep him then that says more about you than him.

Craig Hall has been a great signing for Rovers so if you don't like him too then thank you very much. You think you're better off with Jesterman and Whiting in the halves than Hall?

No wonder you are struggling.

hodgson was nowhere near the player he is now when he was at hull neither was hall they have both got better at rovers and fair play we did not want them josh was average at the time and agar put him in 2nd row when he got his chance never really looked like we would miss him tbh!!
now hall well he is a good squad player but to inconsistent he had one good game against us and we think we should not have let him go come on we are aiming for bigger things then this we don't need to be worried about Craig hall or josh hodgson!! houghton is as good as if not better then hodgson and Craig hall was always average to crap and will be that for the rest of his career!!!

don't really get your point with this because no one has said we are better with them in our halves then a player we don't have??? at the end of the day if fc and rovers had full strength squads he would not be in them!!! hes done more crap things in a derby then he has good things!!
Craigs bad points out way the good!!

Hall was the only attacking flair that we had under Agar and his scoring ratio in a very poor Hull team was greater than that of any other player including Briscoe & Yeaman. I don't think he was given as good a crack of the whip as some others whom have performed far worse. Basically I think he was treated like shat and though his defensive performances were not all that at times we were woeful and leaked tries throughout his time here.
It was the crapness of Agar that failed to develop him further IMO.

Yep, we saw this Friday where he bossed his opposite number..... IMO Josh Hodgson bring more to Rovers than Houghton does Hull and has leap frogged Houghton in the past year or 2

Why hasn't Hall cemented a position in R*vers first team then ?. And this shows just how bad we are .

Salary cap dictates that you can't keep everyone.
If we are lamenting the loss of these two players, it shows you how bad things are!!.

there both not quite there yet tbh but got the potential if they can both keep doing what they are they will be pushing for England. the reason we haven't seen the best of Houghton this year is the fact we take a stone age to get up and play the ball we see how lethal he can be with his scoots when he gets a quick play the ball. he also needs to work on his passing and distribution which are 2 of the reasons he hasn't capped for England yet!!!