Really good game. Not a good effort on Hodgson but shouldn't have resulted in a try. Created plenty tonight and dserves plenty of credit.

overall had a good game, didnt see a lot of horney but then again i think he did a lot in defence,just cant believe we lost, still for 67 min we where far the better team,just the last 12

Maths not your strong point either? Thought you were going to bed dobbo

needs to lose a stone and gain some pace, average at best.

I like what I see of him. Will only improve with familiarity...Westerman, on the other hand...........

Agreed.
Better than what we didnt have

I thought Seymour was very good, the issue for me in the halves is Horne, the sooner we move him to full back the better. Horne's defensive efforts can't be criticised, but he continually offers little in attack. I really hope the Brett Finch rumour is true.

Whilst we still have Russell here, Horne has no chance of being full back, the difference between the 2 is night and day

Wigan want him back, we can only hope that he gets fed up of being back-up to Tomkins and requests to leave.

He's better than Myler,Smith,Gower,Lomax,Handforth,Gale,

It's not just always down to how he's playing, if he has no options either side of him etc he won't be able to perform as good as he can. Put Scott Dureau in the Widnes side and he would be getting the rave reviews as been the best 7 in the league would he. Dureau also has a top 6 next to him in Pryce, we don't.

I'd add Grix as well, personally. As I said earlier, few sides have 2 genuinely top notch halves, most have 1 with a good to very good partner. I think we've now got the good to very good in Seymour, but we still need the top notch partner.

Westerman hit hard in defence and barked out orders, he hasn't had chance to hit form yet

Matty Smith off to Wigan,

Correct. Given the length of time he's been injured I thought he showed up well.

he did but thought was going to give a penalty away everytime he tackled

couple of times he went a bit high but overall he hit well and hard, I think if Russell goes we should try the extra back rower at stand off again but with Westy, he has the flare to play like a stand off when required

Yip...only Wigan that have 2 top drawer halfs.

I'm actually undecided on Leuluai being really top drawer as a half. Catalan have the best pair in SL for me.

Can't believe some people are actually classing Seymour as average at best. He's not world class, I don't think there are any world class halves in the league but Finch and Dureau come close. He's a very good half on his day but to say he's average is stupid imo. Matty Smith, Horne, Hanbury, Gale are average. Seymour is a better standard then those.

I think it's the fact he creates tries that bothers some people.

I wish he created more tbh. He's our most productive player but he's well down the list of try assist's so far this season across SL. In fact as a team we just don't score enough, we are well down the list. To me that shows the lack of creativity that we have in the team.

think seymour is ok, would be nice to have a new stand off for next year to go with him, looking at westerman i think he could be a very good captain

Seymour been good for us, on Saturday he scored a good try and set up two more with excellent kicks.

Horne is steady but not quiet good enough anymore at stand off (If he will be any better at FB who knows), put a good stand off with Seymour and he will improve massively.

Lets be honest if we had won on Saturday the negativity on certain players would not be happening.

He had his best game i'd say and is getting better all the time. His passing and kicking were very good and he just needs the right partner now.