Hull FC - Having their worst ever season
Hull KR - Having one of their best ever seasons

Hull FC still get more support. Go figure.

Thought bishops finger was one of the more sensible kr posters but he’s turned into another obsessed dobbin.
Living in a fantasy world.
Even when kr got hammered at Wembley
The million pound defeat etc
I’d never ever bother to go on kr forum to gloat.
Actually feel sorry for these individuals.
Its rather sad.

Remember the old saying. Form is temporary but class is permanent. Apply as necessary.

Can't argue too much with the dream team for any positions apart from Matty Lees, there is no way in the world he has been better than Ese Ese, stats wise, Ese Ese is better in just apart every area, miles ahead in attacking stats.

Not just Ese Ese, I'd have Sue, amone and Whitebread ahead of him.

I fully agree with Luke Thompson but after that I haven't seen a better prop that Ese'Ese this season and he's playing in a team that's been hammered every week. If he was in a top 4 team he would be absolutely unstoppable. Hard done to in my opinion.
Rest of the team is pretty much spot on I'd say. Could argue a case for a few others but Ese'Ese is a clear cut above the rest.

Really hope Wigan can keep hold of Nsemba. That kid is an absolute freak and his future can be whatever he wants it to be. I'd imagine the NRL clubs are already circling.

Agree, he has been amazing and carried us, Amone has been brilliant too, he is the only other one. Sue has played well recently and scored a few tries, reminds me a bit of Satae, odd bit of flash play, but doesn't do it consistently.

I hope Nsemba goes over soon, love to see British players doing well in the NRL. Him along with Wardle and Lewis should try there hand in the NRL, all good enough to be successful there.

Yeah the NRL thing is a tricky one for me because I agree it's great to see players go over and show what they can do. But I also don't want to lose all our best players to a different competition.

I do at the moment, we wouldn't lose any

It’s interesting that it’s a vote by a panel. I wonder if it is a secret ballot or if they get together (maybe virtually), have a chat and it’s a show of hands. It’s much easier to imagine a conversation taking a ‘who are we going to put in from Saints’ turn than enough people just voting for Lees unprompted.

No Morgan Knowles though, which I think means that an angel gets their wings.

Not sure how it works, did it use to be voted by the players or was that just MOS.

Overall I don't think it's too bad and whilst Lees has had a decent season, think there are alot more deserving players.

Who do people think should be the top 3 for MOS, for me it would be Sneyd, Lewis and Wardke, with Lewis winning it.

Young player has to be Nsemba, but I'd like ti think Martin makes the top 3 Cant think of two better young players this year.

Think Sneyd and Lewis are nailed on for top 3. 3rd place is up for grabs with a few contenders. Wardle as you say is likely one. Dufty has been a bit all over the shop in defence at times but going forwards he's been unplayable at times. Top metre maker by almost 500 and averages over 190 metres a game.
Also wouldn't be surprised, or disappointed, to see Luke Thompson in the top 3. Wigan have an awesome pack and he has led it from the front, putting in 80 minutes performances on a few occasions. Doesn't do the flash stuff of an Ese'Ese or a Mago, but he grafts like hell and has been consistently strong in the middle.
Ultimately Lewis will probably win it. Would have been interesting to see Rovers this year without him for a period because nearly everything they do goes through him.

I think Lewis deserves to win it. He's got better year by year.

Think he will do one more year at Rovers and then try the NRL.

Lewis also been the standout player in the last few months so will likely win it. Sneyd probably more consistent over the season but unlikely to get the nod imo. Both would be worthy winners

I wish he'd f-off now!

Wardle was nowhere near the top at the last published leaderboard which I think was after round 18. Top three was
1 Sneyd
2 Dufty
3 Moylan/Macdonald

You'd imagine that Lewis will be up there by now with Rovers winning most of their games since then and therefore more likely to pick up points. At that cut off point for the published table our highest ranked player was Tex Hoy!

Don't like the way they decide the top 3, you could be the best player for a few games then awful for a majority.

Moylan is the perfect example.

Yes, it's a flawed system. Like the old method of selecting Man of Steel when every SL player picked their top three and many just took the . I remember Miloudi picking up a lot of votes one year.

Fair play to McDonald and Rowley, if we had signed him from Leeds people would have been slating the club but shows what can happen when you have a good system to play in. Salford have turned quite a few careers around the last 5 years or so.

I’d have Luke Thompson in the top 3…been absolutely awesome,can play big minutes and still charge in….Wigans player of the season for me as well.

'dream team is a farce'

'MOS is a flawed system'

'LLS isnt a major trophy'

can i ask what the excuse will be if rovers go on to win the GF ?

It was due to the flying pigs

Clearly too thick to understand the points people were making about the the Man of Steel award.

If you need further evidence of the drop off in quality of Super League, you just need to look at some of the 2024 dream team members.