Well at least we tried

That would be true, but it's all just conjecture - Dobson was an [uexample[/u of the player we need. An old head, with a very good kicking game, and who can also take on the line.

Of course, whether he'd even come back is an unknown. But he's playing reserve grade at the minute and of course he is ooc come November so you'd think he'd be an option if that's where teams are looking to recruit in 2015.

Just shows you how good the NRL is compared to SL..if he's a world beater in this country & desperate cover over there.

This season so hes still a Knights player

How old is Dobson now, about 28?

This poll, somewhat surprisingly, appears fairly conclusive.

28 this year.
I think it's fair to say that Dobbos next long contract will be his last long contract.

All about the Roubles.

Sounds like something Mr Allam would say.

Id give them the next three games together to see how they go. If not we need to find a scrum half again next season.

I'd hope we've already identified one.

I reckon Radford and Tony have as they obviously dont rate Miller. Just hope its the right player.

It needs to be somebody with a proven track record or we might as well just stick with Miller.

Do you have any confidence in Radford and Motu recruiting a top 7? They wanted to sign Gale!

Gale was the only option who was looking like been available, they wouldn't have touched him if it was the right time for snapping players up, & seen as they didn't take over till oct/nov all the available players had been signed, as they are sorted well in advance.

wasnt gale before we signed Rakin, im hoping Tony has some contacts obviously dobson would be perfect.

Dobson ain't going to play for Hull.

Well that's that then

Unfortunately I think you are right.

People saying Leuluai isn't good enough at halfback for us are crazy, won loads of things there for Wigan and currently playing halfback in the NRL, maybe not an organsing half, but 10 times better than our current halfbacks, would be a great signing, again unlikely to happen.

I'd expect it to be Tongan or Kiwi though.

But what would be the point in signing TL? If we don't sign somebody with a kicking game and game management skills.

Because signing him and Sa would make us a top 4 team IMO. His long kicking game isn't the best but the rest of his game is as good as any other half in the league, a great leader with lots of experience in big games.

& can put a shot on..well above his weight!

leuluia isn't the type of half we need.

Miller in a few years may turn out to be a half decent half back but he needs to be playing along side someone with more experience and game management him and Rankin are only young and inexperienced in 2 key rolls one off them needs to go probably miller cause Rankin looks a lot more of a threat with ball in hand and bring in a decent halfback to replace horn to play along side him

yeah, but Miller and Rankin are currently winning this by 82%. Allam claimed victory on 16% of the eligible votes returning a 'yes'. AND this poll isn't worded:

..."Rankin/Miller with Adam Pearson remaining at the club"

Plus I am capable of changing my mind as events evolve and base my opinions on concrete evidence.

67 votes in total when I posted. 9,000 still to go. But I see where you're coming from.