Whiting came on at the right time as dad's army was out on feet and whiting pushed through the line and can cover all positions

not disagreeing, but thursday will be a completely different game, we will need more muscle up front

I know and haven't got a problem with Paea or Carvell (if fit) coming back but Whiting is more important to the side than Hadley ( who did nothing wrong at all) but Whiting gives us more options

Chase played well against Cas but did nothing against us so he'll probably have a blinder on Thursday.

I hope not but I can see it happening. Which proves my point. You don't know which Rangi Chase will show up from game to game.

Was only his 3rd game with his new team who didn't exactly help him. Rangi to a degree will turn up every game. Fact that every season he's been the top or very near try assists, off loads, tackle busts and breaks means if his forwards do anything of note and gets some help via other half and full back it'll turn sour for us awful quick if we don't maintain our standards of Friday

Thought Chase overdid the "flat pass", trying to suck us in, pretty sure he'll go for the quick spread pass on Thursday, hoping we'll still be defending the flat "Flat Pass" if that makes sense.

I'm not just basing my verdict on his three games for Salford. I'm basing it on his time at Cas and games for England. When he's good he's very good there's no denying that. But then you get games like Friday night were he didn't do a lot and had very little impact. Yet some of those stats you mention will have gone up despite this.

As someone else has pointed out, Castleford are looking a lot better without him.

Shaul
Colbon
Crooks
Yeaman
Talanoa
Horne
Miller
Paea
Houghton
Watts
Tuson
Hadley
Westerman
Subs
Heremaia
Thompson
Feka
Bowden/Carvell
Leave HB togehter we need continuaty there and I'd leave Whiting out been poor for me and Thompson playing better.

If it's a straight choice between Thompson or Whiting missing out then I agree. Thompson has really impressed me since joining.

Cas are better as the coach has had an off season, every player knows they had to take up some of the slack, Huby back and fit, signed lynch players like Shenton back to their best. Pretty sure if rangi was there Powell would be getting even more from his team.
Chase stats are constantly well beyond anyone else's. And when his team help him and give him options he's nearly un playable. We need to be good as Friday to stop that from happening. If I was involved with Salford a pre season goal would of been the cup and a good run.

Not sure Whiting has been poor, he has hardly had any gametime and should be before Hadley IMO, as he still offers more in attack and can cover a few positions.

I'd have the same team as above, but with Thomspon starting in the backrow and Whiting on the bench (But used more).

Well we'll just have to agree to disagree on this. I think he's too inconsistent. Unplayable one week, might as well be absent the next.

He's never absent. Just means one week he's average instead of ridiculously outrageous! Only 1 time in 5 years has he not been top try assist maker and only missed by a few even though only played 16 games, last year was top off loader,never have i known a half back as top off loader. Also top tackle buster. If his and his teams timing was fractionally better they'd have been a few more breaks from them.if he clicks they'll be worth at least 10 more points

So much for agreeing to disagree...

Nobody expecting Miller to cop a ban for the high shot on Johnson when they scored their first try?

I am now!

I thought that when it happened as it was right in front of me. Hicks did go and have a word with miller about it let's hope he's ok and available to play on Thursday

If Miller cops a ban and Morley escapes unpunished I really will believe there's a conspiracy going on at the RFL.

Just after a minute in for those who have not seen it. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=GDhNfjX ... ry9o-s_2wI Link should be allowed as it is a SL official channel.

Just after a minute in for those who have not seen it. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=GDhNfjX ... ry9o-s_2wI Link should be allowed as it is a SL official channel.

No Charge for Miller and Morley got off theres a suprise

Not sure it's that Radford doesn't rate him, more just a reflection of his form. Over his time with us, it's typically been noticeable that we are a better team when he's on the pitch. I don't think that's been the case (at least as much) this year.

32 "incidents" reviewed over this weekend, 10 in rovers match against wakefield.

32, but I get your point. It's almost as if some people might have upset the judiciary system or something.

Quote ="hullbg"Just after a minute in for those who have not seen it. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=GDhNfjX ... ry9o-s_2wI Link should be allowed as it is a SL official channel.'" Question for any rule experts out there; Should Crooks' try have been pulled back for a Salford penalty? Shaul was almost facing the touch line when he played the ball which I thought wasn't allowed. Or does it not matter as long as the ball is played backwards?

Quote ="hullbg"Just after a minute in for those who have not seen it. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=GDhNfjX ... ry9o-s_2wI Link should be allowed as it is a SL official channel.'" Question for any rule experts out there; Should Crooks' try have been pulled back for a Salford penalty? Shaul was almost facing the touch line when he played the ball which I thought wasn't allowed. Or does it not matter as long as the ball is played backwards?