You realise that play-offs are the [itraditional[/i way of deciding the champions in RL, right? Not something just invented by Sky?

Oh look, you're back.

Yes, up until 1973 if my memory serves me correctly.

However it was most often a top 4 contest and played as a straight 1v4 and 2v3 format without this silly aussie nonsense of letting in more than half the table and some teams getting 2 chances.

1973 to 1996 it was the league leaders who were champions and there wasn't much compliant about it (or nostalgia for the playoff method)

I just don't like the fact a team can finish 8th and somehow be playing for the championship !

One of the reasons that many see this is the big final is that SKY tell everyone that it is. From round 1 they bang the drum about Old Trafford so not surprising it has a raised profile compared to the Challenge Cup which is only mentioned when the games are actually on.

Being pedantic, theirs is half the table, not more than half.

I agree that 8 teams is too many. I'd have preferred it stick with 6 in a 14 team league. I guess it will change again next season with the league restructure. Really needs to be the top half only.

I don't have a problem with the teams that finish top and second getting some advantage in the playoffs, whether that's a bye through the first round or whatever. In fact the 'old' top 6 format worked just fine for me.

In short, I don't think the playoffs themselves are the issue - it's the current format that needs changing.

Aaron Heremaia is up before the disciplinary tomorrow. www.therfl.co.uk/the-rfl/disciplinary/item?4805

Aaron Heremaia is up before the disciplinary tomorrow. www.therfl.co.uk/the-rfl/disciplinary/item?4805

Quote ="Rogues Gallery"Aaron Heremaia is up before the disciplinary tomorrow. www.therfl.co.uk/the-rfl/disciplinary/item?4805'" EGP and back for the following week. At least the RFL are being consistent with these tackles. (Mcshane was banned last week for the same)

Quote ="Rogues Gallery"Aaron Heremaia is up before the disciplinary tomorrow. www.therfl.co.uk/the-rfl/disciplinary/item?4805'" EGP and back for the following week. At least the RFL are being consistent with these tackles. (Mcshane was banned last week for the same)

Think Bowden has done little wrong when he has played, and has probably been unfortunate to miss so many games. Likewise Johnson has played ok, and while he is maybe not as effective driving the ball, his defence never let's anyone down. With Green as well I think our second string of forwards can still do a job