Do you think Richard Horne, on this years form, would have been good enough to secure a starting half back spot in last years U20's State of Origin? My personal opinion is no. However we are lucky enough to have one of the 4 starters from last years U20's SOO, signed up, and you suggest he should play second fiddle to Richard Horne not only for this year but next year too! Baffling...

No sympathy from you then



The guy suffered a severe concussion not long back, and couple this with him playing catch-up with match fitness, perhaps you need to cut the guy some slack



As for Richard Horne, he has always been an effective player in the halves - ask Paul Cook - and has come back to full fitness after some very serious injuries. Pity he is side lined at the moment, it seems to have contributed toward taking the wind out of FCs sails (although IMO its FCs middle which seems to have run out of 'wind').

What about Horne back to centre?

I think we have enough centres

3 way shoot out between horne, miller and holdsworth. Best 2 get to play. Overall, horne has been much better than holdsworth this season (who has had as many poor to average games as he has good games) so maybe it's between holdsworth and miller who partners horne when he come back?

Would seem the obvious answer to me as well. Plus with 3 fit, there is no need to play anyone who isn't 100% and those starting know they are under pressure to play well to keep their place.

I think Holdsworths had his best games with Horne along side him.

I reckon we should see how he plays alongside a settled Miller 1st. Since they've only played together once its a bit too soon to decide who partners him better.