i knew tickle should have been picked!!! good season,good kicker

Well done Tom....

Tompkins junior can kick a bit too cant he

Widdop will kick

What I think too.

shouldn't you have wrote 'well done Tom Briscoe'

Looking at the squad it wouldn't surprise me if O'Loughlin played at 6 alongside Tomkins.

You would have thought so wouldn't you.
Seems some folks from both sides can't see past their obsession.

I think its a possibility.

How much has Widdop played this year at the Storm? One good performance against a French team who'd struggle to bust a grape in a fruit fight doesn't make you ready to mix it with the best at test level. Sad indictment of the lack of viable alternatives in SL. I'd have taken Myler instead of Robinson, at least he has the potential to make the grade, whereas Robinson will only ever be a good SL player. Briscoe and Hall on the wings for me, if Tom misses out it could only be to Cudjoe, really not convinced that Goulding is doing anything but making up the numbers.

Robinson and Tompkins for me, O'Loughlin 13.

good luck tom! but with mcnamara as coach, am fearing the worst, two big losses against the aussies and kiwis', and a scrappy win over png

The Aussies have lost a bit of fire power in the centres and I expect us to compete with nz again.

Bit worried at 7 but nz have problems there and the Aussies are missing thurston.

Well with Thurston missing they may struggle having to rely on the likes of Carney, Cronk or Prince. Not to mention probably another dozen or so half backs better than ours. I think they could replace the full 13 and still beat our team at a canter.

Didn't realise, thought they just had thurston.

Cheers buddy.

Fully deserved for Tom, he and Hall are the standout wingers in SL.

Hall is overrated in my opinion and think he might get found out

Well if Widdup is good enough to be Melbournes 6 next year maybe he'll get a go there for England?

Well done to Tom, but cant see him getting the nod over Hall and Goulding

I wouldn't have done, I think Robinson has been very good, pretty consistent all year round and probably deserves a chance.

I agree with you about Goulding, just doesn't have that 'wow' factor IMO.

Only needs to get in over one of them, I'd have Hall and Briscoe myself but granted it's a tight call.

Good finisher, but mostly because Wigan are great at getting it wide for him to finish. Tom is great at making his own tries out of nothing, off his own performance.