There is no advantage gained? Ridiculous.

Would have thought something can be put on report in the lead up to a try but I bow to your greater knowledge of the rules. Was screaming at Silverwood for taking us back to our 20 but in the end dont think it mattered, got to go as my red n white neighbours have just arrived home, fun times ahead me thinks

I don't think they have to be put on report during the game - they can be cited afterwards by RFL?

It seems stupid, I know, especially as if Tansey had been fouled in the act of kicking, the pen would've been given where the ball landed, I'm also still not completely sure whether Silverwood blew his whistle before Whiting got tackled though

MoM for me today, reads the game better than any other in Super League, if he had pace he'd be an international, get him signed up, 3 year deal.

IMHO he probably has one of the best rugby brains in our squad, and although he has a lack of pace, his ability to read the opposition gives him a head start anyway, and I think he's vital to keep considering the amount of positions he covers, and covers brilliantly.

Have always rated Rich, his reading of the game is second to none.

Must agree with a few other posters on here, he was my MOM as his defensive display saved us from conceding tries on more than one occasion.

Whiting does have a great footballing brain, I also think his talents are wasted unless he is playing 6 or 13.

He may not be the fastest player on the park but neither was John Newlove when we signed him. John had lost what pace he had, long before we signed him. What Bunting did though was get others, who had pace, playing off Newlove and it paid dividends.

I'm just concerned that Agar would never consider Whiting for a pivot role, for fear of upsetting a "star"

Good post. Very few of our players would have gone the length of the field today in that situation. He would be world class with that extra yard. Agar missed a trick last year when not giving him a role at 6 or 13 when the season had ended for us. It would have been a great chance to see what he could offer in those positions.

For me, Richard was his usual honest dependable self. I see him as Fitz replacement (he is still only early 20's) and will give us that extra pivot and ideas in games. He has that air of unpredictability about him abd that has got to be worth a new deal.

Me and a few people i know have been screaming for him to be a 6 or 13 but even having him in the centres or at fullback is better than keeping him out the 17. considering he came to hull as a 6, he's not done bad in every other position he's played

He'd be an excellent 13. I don't see why anyone should be upset about trying it, either. It's not like Fitz can't play prop or second row.

If Tickle needs a rest after taking a knock, it may be a good time to try whiting at 13 on monday and move fitz into second row if he plays.

My player of the season so far. Always gives 100% and never let's us down. I feel he should be looking at international honours. Ok a lack of pace but his utility value is fantastic. For all his lack of pace there was not a single Hull player near him when he made that break. As for putting players on report. For me we were penalised as unless the Rovers player was going to be sent off we gained nowt from that decision and in deed if we had knocked on at the first play the ball we would have been under immense pressure. Poor rule if Coddy is correct.

M.O.M today, no doubt. The lad is class, probs got the best pair of hands at the club and arguably the best rugby brain. Would love to see him at 13 on Monday with Fitz dropping to second row but he will have to play in the back line as we now have no wingers at all. I reckon turner will come into centre with Rich being stuck out on the wing.

Spot on. I'd love to see him get a run at loose forward.

Outstanding again today.THe guy is a class act.

rich whiting was superb again today, great positional play and reading of the game

agreed, he had a blinder,

maybe the 1 player you have who might get in our side

Totally agree, Whiting's a class act with a great rugby brain. What he lacks in pace, he gains with his head and for what it's worth, people keep banging - on about his lack of pace etc. but when he does break where is everyone else?
Most of his breaks leave him on his own making him look more slower than he is. With someone backing up we could have had some great trys.
I agree, this could be an opportunity to see Whiting in the second row or L/F.

His pace is fine - it's just not lightening. He made plenty of ground on that interception, for example.

That's what I'm trying to say. He has good pace, and makes the breaks, usually breaking the line. It's just frustrating that when he does, there is usually no other players anywhere near him to continue the break.
You don't necessarily need devastating pace, just good back up.

He's slow for a 3/4 whichever way you spin it

Out standing today. Saved a certain 6 points. When he intercepted and calmed the ship with a 70 metre stroll. We played lad.

Richy W is one class player and has consistently turned up every time he pulls on the black and white shirt. Versatile and switched on he is just what we need.