R Horne is poor at No6 . He makes Thorman look even worse than he is and thats not hard!
Horne`s passing is terrible to say the least .

His best games this season have been at f/back

Accepted, so what is the point of lauging or rolling eyes just because others may have a different opinion

Why not just swap Motu and Horney round. Motu has looked pretty sharp since he came back from injury. Did'nt Motu play in the half backs when he was at brisbane any way?

because i disagree with that or have a different opinion, which again is what a forum is all about, DiFFERENING OPINIONS, which create a debate

Initially you never actually debated you just laughed at an opinion, that is easy to do, debating is presenting an argument for and or against.

look i disagree with some of the posters views exspecially regarding richard horne, as everytime i see a thread such as this one his name pops up, what a surprise, there are far worse players at HULLFC than him, believe me.

Fair point, I am not interested in changing your opinion, I know Rich he is a great guy, however my opinion is based on his performance only.I agree there are worse players than him, unfortunatley he is in a pivotal position. I actually believe his best games have been at fullback. I would love to see Rich regain his form as I would most of them.And if it takes a spell on the bench to achieve this I believe this is what should happen. We will agree to disagree

theres something we agree on

i though he played well there and FWIW would like to see Berro given a chance in the halves. danny houghton to play hooker with tommy lee.

Could be a good option to improve his performance also. I rate houghton and tommy is one of the few who have improved this season.

i will be one of the first to say i slated tommy last season, but this season he has improved a lot. always liked danny always gives 110% , relly think Berro would give us some more options at halfback,

Horney definitely looked better at fullback then Motu has since he's come back so if Rich is dropped, Motu has to be too.

i agree

TBF I think we all slated Tommy last season

It is great he has come good though, Danny is a grafter who is still improving so not the finished article yet he should have a long sucessfull career ahead of him.I have as discussed in a different thread being disapointed with Berro, maybe he needs to have his operation now in order to gage his fitness for next year.I agree if fully fit he would offer options at h/back though I also think he would produce a good prformance at centre.

trouble is Agar will put the same players out in the same positions and opt for the same boring play, Berro needs his op now. as i would rather that (when the seasons virtually gone), then have him plagued with injury again next year.
would also swap whiting to looseman, as he has no pace for a centre and radfords just a plodder.

I don't I'd have Washy at 13 before anyone at the club.

Horne was Hull's worst player on Saturday. If Thorman had performed as badly as Horne did, there would have been a 300 post thread and a bunch of morons with avatars saying he is crap.

yeah I forgot about Washy another very good option

Disagree about Horne being our worst player but fully agree with what you are saying with regards to Thorman.

Is the link to Hornes poor perfromances the fact that he has moved back to 6 maybe he wanted the fullback spot and now is as feed up as we are.

not ever going slag this guy off the effort he has put into this club since he was 16

As for the rest Houghton to 9 berrigan to 7 lee to Dewsbury.

Here are my thoughts..


:1so13lhkDowes:1so13lhk is Hull top tackler for the club and works hard every match, maybe too hard which is why he looks tired. - Keep him in

:1so13lhkTickle:1so13lhk has been poor for a while but now Hall has gone we dont have a goalkicker so that is why he is picked - Drop him

:1so13lhkRadford:1so13lhk looks like he is just not trying - Drop him

:1so13lhkBerrigan:1so13lhk injured - Drop him

:1so13lhkThorman

for me

Radford has had it

Horne's off the boil but I feel he could turn it around

Tickle, Dowes, King, Thackray aren't pulling their weight

Berrigan should not be playing with his injury

and Manu, Moa, Maloney, Raynor, Calderwood should go find another club, because they are wasted here, Agar has no idea how to use them.

and Thorman is trying, but he's just hopeless

and also my opinion!!

ive thought that tickle has played ok and dowes aswell,but id deffo get shut ov radders as just walks into tackles,drop yeaman been poor and bring back hall,kingy drop him