It'd be interesting to see Briscoe feeding Calderwood, definitely, but I don't think Horne should lose his place.

FFS give the guy a break. Some people have had it in for him before a game was even played.
He has had very little ball, no real decent passes and yet it's all his fault.


He's been solid in defence and willing to help the forwards, taking the ball out. Lets give him some credit and stop knocking him, hardly going to build his confidence that.
And to that idiot in the East Stand shouting abuse at him, get a life and support our players.

You will be crying after the Derby when we have kicked to him . All those High balls can't wait .

In Australia he was like a frightened rabbit caught in some head lights .

In the Derby, Crocker and Laukai will crush all your players

He was probably still in shock at his call up and the lack of quality opposition for his shirt.

So useless, yet he still kept Fox out of the squad.

Was Craig Hall or Richard Horne that keeps missing his centre out but giving him a shocking pass.

Some people feel the need for a scapegoat though and i guess Calderwood is the new Blacklock. Again i thought he did everything asked of him.

His 4 tackles back to back under their posts to try and force an error didnt show any laziness.

Deserves more credit for that, was an awesome effort.

He wont get it though will he!

No he won't. Why? God only knows. His partnership with the 2 Horne's in attack hasn't clicked yet but it will, all you can ask of him after that is to put a shift in defensively which so far i'm more than happy with him for.

he seems over egar to get the ball and over runs it.i think he is just to enthusiastic(pardon my spelling lol)to do well and starts jumping around like a kangaroo to get the ball and goes too far forward to recieve the ball lol.but did give some good passes out

He was also the one who put Horney through the gap for the no try When Yeamo should of given it.

At the end of the day, it was a bad night at the office. Too many errors and too many players having off night at the same time. All we can do is hope we put it right next week. Lets face it, would we swap our six results with those of Wire, Salford, Bradford and Celts (all right I know the last 2 have only played 5, but you get my point).

It hurts cos we lost, but as Agar said in his after match interview we wasn't going to go through the season unbeaten. Its just a shame we have to try and find scapegoats after what was a 1 point defeat to a good team after out scoring them 4 tries to 3.

Agreed, its easily overlooked about the work he did to put Horne through the gap etc as some FC fans just seem like they need someone to have a go at, even when we're winning. This just has a greater emphasis put on it when we lose. The same idiots sat behind me were just slating him from start to finish, even the good stuff that he did wasnt good enough.

I really do wish some FC fans would just not bother turning up for the attitude they bring with them to the games.

Different attitude from the players this year, shame some fans can't do the same!

Youre not wrong.

You could tell how much the defeat hurt them at the end of the game, will hopefully make them more determined to put it right next week.

agar will certainly put it right,he will be fuming i would think

I think Calderwood is looking for work and is desperate to score tries. He's lacking a decent centre, I mean that offload from Briscoe which went behind him wasn't even his wing!

The same has happened at Fc for last few years we buy a pacey winger but fail to play them outside a quality centre, then we all moan when they are not doing well. The reason Briscoe and Raynor score many tries is because they are fortunate to be on the same side of the pitch as Yeaman and Manu.

if calderwood stays on the right wing to see the best of him attacking wise he'd have tobe partnered by hall or whiting or moved to the left to work off manu.

If crocker gets here and is allowed to play his natural position calderwood will do very well off him.

Have they ever.

Spot on.

Exactly right. Maybe should have scored in the corner but getting over the surprise of receiving a catachable ball probably did for him there. Works hard and does look disappointed at times but that's because of a lack of quality service. His defence and covering work is exceptional but too subtle for many fans to notice.

Spot on, its good to see him popping up all over too and if that Briscoe pass had stuck he would have scored. Just one of those nights i think.

Hall has already shown he can link in the line and play as a pivot from 1. Whiting is no where near the first team on current form.

i dont mean right now dave, hall and whiting have the ability to put their winger away.

i'm not knocking greame or kirk by the way their stronger in other departments.