Just my experiences of them, i will edit with reasons why, although some wont be fair, just personal issues!

Shane Endacott, Dave Moffat weren't the best.

Oh and I'd have Brad Hepi as captain.

I didnt mind Brad Hepi. His defence was outstanding the day we won the league at Huddersfield, and anyone who has a song sang to him by the fans cant be that bad! HEPI HEPI HEPI!

Yeah Jamie Smith was awful, did we sign him from Workington??

We got Logan Campbell from Workington who was a pretty decent player too.

Temu is only remembered for his hit on Darren Rogers at Salford, dont think anyone has seen Rogers since!

I know hes not foreign but worrincy at the bulls would take some beating for worst player.

very harsh on huntsman to be fair, he didnt do much wrong

Like I say, more to do with my expectations of what a guy that size could do

says it all

FB is a hard position TBF, out of all our overseas FB's are would say it would either be Sammut or Byrne.

Samutt
Heron
Endacott
Ronson
Seru
Webber
Henjak
Spring
Can't think of a bad hooker TBH, Purtell was maybe the worst I have seen.
Hutch
Lauaki
Mcnicolas (maybe a bit harsh there)
David

Backrow is hard can't think of too many bad overseas players we have had there.

Plenty of English ones though

He was only tall though, no real girth. Personally I think its easier to tackle someone tall and thin as opposed to short and fat.

He put effort in just never broke a tackle

but his game was as a stopper not a runner, and thats what he did very well... but your right easier to tackle a racing snake than a tank

Sorry not trying to be argumentative but I think thats hard on Todd too, wasnt the most skilful player in the world but hey that lad gave 100% every time he pulled on his jersey dont you think???
His last game ever was an example of that !!

Skinny is looked on negatively because he was a wasted quota place. You cannot doubt he gave his all for the club

Neil Henry, Ivan Henjak and Ian Heron.

I was agreeing with you

didnt do much right tho either, terrible forward

when you think about it, we proably had more cack overseas players than good ones

Amazing how time skews some peoples memory. Sammut only played one game at St Helens for Hull, which we lost 27-14.

I think it works the other way as well. Last night we watched the DVD of Leeds v Hull at Headingley in 2006. Because I have quite a few DVDs of the 2005 and 2006 season, particularly games in which Shayne McMenemy made a really telling contribution, he's becoming more of a legend each year in my eyes. Confused as to whether he was really a journeyman backrower with a decent boot on him, or whether seeing him score 2 in the semi at the Galpharm and force the error that led to us winning the cup umpteen times means he's an All Time FC Great.

Very very underrated player . Sharp shouldn't have got rid of him when he should

very VERY under rated player by everyone except oppositon who knew him all too well not to respect him....

How has it skewed my memory? He had one game there, and it was awful. He had other poor displays, just that one still stands out

Anyone remember a fat useless prop forward called dave brown who came across in the late 80's? Hardly played and was sent home early because he was garbage and lazy. We did sign some rubbish in the late 80's and early 90's