G. Horne should replace Whiting at centre imo but, Whiting should then go to looseman.

If Whiting loses his place and is not injured then Agar is really showing himself to be utterley clueless.

And Radford to Rochdale.



Again.

Appalling decision if true, and further proof of Agar not having either the stones or intelligence to make the right calls. If he hasn't got the nuts to carry it through and do something about it, he shouldn't go round telling papers it's the more established players who are responsible.

If anyone at the club's reading, please ask Agar to do me a favour: f**k off and take 5 drives and a kick with you.

Didnt say whiting had, but i also said for once i can see where agar is coming from here. I wouldnt however drop whiting i'd play him at 13.

It appears a natural strength of his, he doesnt have to try that hard.

That's a team that on paper should be able to put in a decent performance, I might be tempted to have Radford on the bench as an interchange prop instead of Lee/Houghton (probably Houghton).

The team all season should have been one to put in a decent performance!

G. horne is a very poor centre and if anyone wants evidence of that look at 2 things. The improvement in Calderwoods performances from playing with Rich Whiting and the tries we've conceeded due to G. Horne/R. Horne in defence.

Very good point

Largepants ??? Maybe but comfort wins over style every time !!! Have more loose skin than ever before and it needs storing somewhere



Unsure of how Thack's conducts himself off the pitch but is sure to get some leeway from me if he's making the effort on the pitch. It those who are loafing when away from the club and on the pitch I have an issue with.

If G Horne comes in for Whiting thats fine as long as Whiting is moved to 13. If its simply going to be G Horne in and Whitng out then Agar really is more of a clueless muppet than I thought.

Whiting for me has done a good job and for me Horne needs to earn his place not just come staright back in. If thats the case it beggars belief and no wonder some players retain their place no matter how the are.

Have to agree with all that, Drop Radford before Whiting.

The most worrying thing for me is that it seems Agar rates G Horne more than Whiting, with them both being OOC that worries me that he might keep Horne over Whiting.

Absolute disgrace if whiting has been dropped and I wouldn't blame he is he didnt stay at Hull next year.

I thought he had re-signed

I may have missed it but haven't seen anything offcial.

If Whiting is dropped maybe we should sing theres only one Richard Whiting to get our point across.

what is this clueless runt, thinking of dropping Whiting???
you'v just got to laugh at this inept, idiotic clown, whos passing himself of as a SL head coach? he aint got the b*lls to drop the like of Radders, Tickle etc, so he makes a stand and drops the one guy, who has been playing well, and giving his all, part of me wants us to get hammered by Salford tonight, it would be worth it, so this fool (and mavis his sidekick) gets the sack!

Radford I'll give you but Tickle? He needs to be spelled correctly in the game instead of playing for 80mins and not expecting fatique to get the better of him. But lets face it until our coaches can master the art of when, how and who to interchange were pretty much fubar'd.

None of our players are used properly which makes most of them suffer. This is primarily Tickle and Manu who i wouldnt be surprised if he tries to get 75 mins out of each of them and gives Burnett the last 10.

Said the same to my dad last night. One of our only players with form and he may be getting dropped. Would pick Whiting over G. Horne every day of the week.

just not been made public yet

Wish Agar would

Whiting not in the 17



Radford - Prop
Berrigan - Bench
Thackray - Bench.
Tickle- LF

What has G Horne done to deserve an immediate recall??

Have to say that team selection is pretty mystifying.

And leaving Whiting out just stinks IMO.

If I was him I'd be tearing the contract up right about now and looking for a club with a coach who knows what he's doing.