To be honest looking at your line up it's decent. Back row on paper is up there with best in league when on form. Best half backs for years. Pace in the backs, shaul, lineham, michaels, rankin. Enough to worry me for the derby. Not a fore gone conclusion by any means.

one match i would play yeaman, shaul in brings more pace, we have the players to win, but we have said that every match this season lol

Dangerous to play so soon after a rib injury,carney tried it for the cats and lasted 15mins and not been sighted since.

He did not go off because of a rib injury it was a leg injury

problem is he cant tackle

Doubt there's a club in SL without at least one player 'jabbed up' from week to week.

just because it's common doesn't make it right.

if FC carry on like they are, the crowd will deserve pain relief!

I have to agree with your team but as you say its guaranteed Radford will bring Yeaman back in despite the fact we need some real pace out wide and Talanoa would be a handful at centre.
If it wasn't the Derby and Ellis was fit I would have dropped Westerman but think playing him for a while in the second row whilst Ellis is out may be better for the team to utilise his ball handling wider out.
I hope Cunningham is fit because Howarth is a waste of a salary.

Don't imply it's only us that do it then.

Every club does it but in relation to rib injuries, and I speak as an ex player at a much lower level, they are among the painful injuries around
It was bad enough trying to get through every day normal duties never mind playing......tough feckers, these lot.

I implied no such thing. \What are you cooking for Lee's tea?

And now silly remarks, the mask is slipping.

I've had a rib cartilage injury, did it playing golf a while back. Nothing you can do with them and to jab them up and play won't really have a detrimental effect on the injury. But as he has two now it must be about comfort generally for him as he must not be able to train with it, unless jabbed up of course.

I can say with definitive experience that there are few players that are not carrying an injury from the first three weeks of a season and there will be more than one player "jabbed up" in each team... as kids get fitter, faster and bigger such is that the injuries will pile up
Then as the need to keep the wages on the pitch grows, then the jabs become more frequent
I have never gone for all this "we have lots of cover in all areas" rubbish coaches spout, my experience is that the rest of a squad is there "just in case" but not as replacements IF the glory boy can be gotten onto the field ..thats jenga im afraid

On paper it isn't a bad lineup, but sadly they appear to spend all week practicing barging it up the middle and nothing else

Id play Tommo at interchange prop and have Abdul on the bench. Feka looked unfit last time out and is a liability in defence. Abdul also has a kicking game

I think will find out he is out with a rib injury.

[url=http://www.totalrl.com/todd-carney-suffers-another-injury/Probably not[/url

Not a fan of these jabbing up as it can cause problems for the player through rehab. But if it's needed it's needed. Bring back good old cheggers!

As with the cover in all places I don't buy it either. Likes of Logan and Lancaster look like fantastic prospects but I can't help but think that they would be dominated by rovers Kelly and mantalato on the flanks but as always it's a derby.

at present players would be looking to miss this one where at all possible so they cant be blamed for the kicking we will possibly get... then they cant be blamed, even radford is pulling a sickie

also think this is the first time in recent history i do believe even if we win the derby we will all still think were up the creek ...this one will make no difference either way i fear

get a grip

of what the reality ??, think i already have there, no black and white glasses here...
I have supported them since a young child but can see the reality

Reality, What like players taking a sickie when its the match all players want to be involved in

so you truly believe they all want to be involved in this do you?? genuinely