Think most people have similar teams, however i would have old Sid at centre over yeamo.

And Swain is by far the best super league era player we have had, and am astonished someone put Triester above him.

David Maiden
David Maiden
David David Maiden
He's got no hair but we don't care
David David Maiden

Thats what I thought.

Jason Smith

Agreed!

Prescott
Raynor
Yeaman
Barnett Snr
Best
Cooke
Smith (Tony)
Carvell
Swain
Greenhill
Kearney
Grimaldi
Smith (Jason)

Tony
Thackery
Manu
Berrigan

Prescott
Best
Barnett
Yeaman
Raynor
R Horne
J Smith
Greenhill
Berrigan
Logan
Ryan
Kearney
Grimaldi

Subs
Swain
Manu
Mcmenemy
Carvell

I'd go with that, but swap Domic for Yeaman and Logan for Thackray.

TBF its a tough call between the two, but judged on his achievements at Hull and his standing within the game i'd side with Richard Swain.

Pretty much the 13 I would choose apart from Paul Broadbent for Craig Greenhill (can't believe nobody has yet included Broadbent)

Have to agree. Best player I have seen in a Hull shirt.

Triester above Swain has to be a joke doesnt.

Prescott
Best
Barnett
Yeaman
Raynor
Cooke
Horne
Dowes
Swain
Carvell
Grimaldi
Mcmenemy
Smith.

Jason Smith was head and shoulders above any player thats played for Hull in the super league era. Simply a class above anyone else. Possibly the most talented player to play Super League. He's the only player I've seen capable of winning matched by himself. Swain had the graft and the professionalism but Smithy oozed class.

Again I have to agree with that. Swain was the consumate pro but joined a team which was developing under the guidance of Smith (on the pitch anyway

). I am sure players like Horne and Cooke learnt a hell of a lot playing with Smith.

Smith had all the skills needed, he could change a game at the drop of a shoulder, put in a 40/20, brilliant attacking kicker and not a bad ball stealer!

Jason Smith is definately the best player you have had in the SL era. But Swain was a cracking player aswell.

looking through the posts the backs seem to be lining up like this
1.prescott
2.best
3.barnett snr
4.yeaman (good call on domic though whoever put that forward)
5.raynor
6.cooke
7.horne

noticed some have swapped best/barnett to the left but these were deffo a right sided partnership - the only time we have looked truly threatening down that side in the superleague era

forward line up is not as clear cut perhaps someone could complete
it from amalgamating the votes

8.
9.swain
10.
11.
12.kearney
13.j smith

for me;
presscott
raynor
yeaman
barnett snr
best
horne
t.smith
carvell
swain
greenhill
kearney
macmenemy
j smith

subs;
berrigain
grimaldi
cooke
broadbent

Prescott
Raynor
Yeaman
Barnett Snr
Best
Cooke
T. Smith
Carvell
Swain
Greenhill
Kearney
Grimaldi
J. Smith

Logan
Mcmenemy
Manu
Horne

1-13 Richard Swain

But that would mean we would draw 0-0 everygame

Agree with your team apart from Greenhill...i never rated him tbh....i would be tempted with Broadbent.

Not quite true, he was a bit of a mean goalkicker on the quiet!

2-0 to the Hull FC, 2-0 to the Hull FC....................

1.Prescott
2.Best
3.Barnett Snr
4.Yeaman
5.Raynor
6.Cooke
7.R.Horne
8.Dowes
9.Swain
10.Carvell
11.Mcmenemy
12.Kearney
13.J.Smith

14.Berrigan
15.Logan
16.Greenhill
17.Maher

1 Steve Prescott
2 Colin Best
3 Richie Barnett Snr
4 Kirk Yeaman
5 Gareth Raynor
6 Richard Horne
7 Jason Smith
8 Ewan Dowes
9 Richard Swain
10 Garreth Carvell
11 Adam Maher
12 Stephen Kearney
13 Tony Grimaldi

14 Scott Logan
15 Shaun Berrigan
16 Willie Manu
17 Motu Tony

Who can forget our Spanish international full back!!

Now edited.