I was just thinking that. Out of the two Buchanan currently looks the better.

Absolutely. If you're going to hypothesise about moments in a game you should be even handed and reflect both ways.

Had Faraimo not knocked in the first half, we hadn't missed touch and as you say made that tackle behind the line then we would

Lots of things happen in the game which changes the outcome, they knocked on a few times but I don't remember one if those being a scoring pass. Both teams made mistakes, we just about managed to hang on, no luck at all.

Bit harsh to judge Scott on one game, his first in 6 months or more.

I'd keep Buchanan though, think he will do well in the backrow long term

Disappointing evening for some. I'll take a win with 11 missing or whatever it is, let's hope we get some bodies back on Sunday.

That's fair enough tbh. Forgot he won't have played for ages.
Does seem a shame if we aren't able to hang onto him.

My judgement is based on all the times I've seen them. Buchanan has always impressed me, Scott on the other hasn't.

Which makes you wonder why Buchanan didn't start, and have Scott off the bench

Lucky or not we won. After how poor we've been I'm pleased with that. You've highlighted our shortcomings but didn't you find any positives in the performance?

Did you hear our fans singing Old Faithful out again...

Big Chris will be tired after that lengthy spell.

I'm gonna give Mahe an honourable mention.
Think we are generally one of the cr@ppest teams for challenging for our own kicks, but ultimately, his leap tonight won us the game.

Did we win "in spite of" or "because" we were missing all or some of these?

Personally I think some of the replacements may have more than made up for what they lacked in quality in enthusiasm and endeavour.

Let's hope Last rewards this and doesn't just revert to the "first team players" on reputation alone.

Agreed. Several won't be available anyway I guess - Taylor, Sneyd, Shaul, Jones - but if Cator is fit he should definitely play for example.

https://twitter.com/TheRFL/status/13041 ... 31782?s=19 Savelio wins MOM with 52% of the #ourleague vote

https://twitter.com/TheRFL/status/13041 ... 31782?s=19 Savelio wins MOM with 52% of the #ourleague vote

I thought he went well tonight. I'd be tempted to start with him against Cas.

MOM for hide and seek?

We somehow need to keep Watts under control to have any chance, that's pretty much what Price said tonight for Warrington. Not sure how but Sao and Satae starting?

Best game for us by far mate,

Grab his nuts

He won it by a nose

That can't be true. The ususal "brains" on here have already decided he's rubbish, despite the fact he ran his blood to water even after Danny attacked him. A great performance and if he can avoid any more injuries he'll be a real star for us.

What? they're lucky to have scored more points than the opposition. You're unreal.

Forgotten about Sao. Good to have options. Hopefully Taylor is not far away from a return.

Plenty of effort, and quite a few had a real dig.

Love how Cator plays. Savelio is a class act, it’s just getting him on the pitch.

Shall i remind you of what you said just i case you are thinking of making the journey on Sunday with the black and white army


Another positive was the fantastic away support, Desperately poor performance but Old Faithful could be heard loud and proud on TV. Well done to all those who made the journey.