Disagree judging by the level of confidence on SM by some of their supporters. Serious egg on face for them if not true, so assuming it is.

HDM: "Sources have confirmed to Hull Live that the Fijian hooker will not be swapping West Hull for East Hull with Hull FC hoping to tie Lovodua down for the foreseeable future, leaving the Robins still on the hunt for a new hooker to pair up with Jez Litten in 2023. Rovers will be able to speak to off-contract players at other clubs from May 1st."

Turned them down? Find that rather hard to believe.

Jordan Johnstone

If True as you quote ' Turned them down ' I am glad as there are better out there I believe

I'm led to believe that when we signed Joe that the deal included the option of a further two years in the clubs favour.
Hopefully be annonced in the next couple of weeks.

Like Matt Parcell you mean?

He has a good work rate but HKR work with two running nines who have pace.
Johnstone hardly runs from dummy half and doesnt have pace.
Even though he has featured a lot this season mainly due to injuries to other players, i dont think he has a future here after this season.

Who knows what HKR will play like next season, who’s going to be coach? Radford may end up there (tongue firmly in cheek) Think it will be Maguire?

Could do with Mason Lino. Great player.

Seen some rumours on social media, would be a great signing, but doubt it would happen, under contract for next season for a start.

I'd happily go with a 3 combination of Litten, Connor, McNamara, Hookem and Truman as our 1,6 and 7 for next season and build for the future.

Maybe keep Gale at the right price, but needs a big few games.Give Houghton one more year, but not to play as a 80 minute player, play him with Lovodua and Balmforth.

Replace Ma'u with Mellor and have him, Savelio, Griffin, Severs and Lane fighting for the back row position.

Centres, Scott, Mitch, Wynne and Carlos.

Save some cap, upgrade young players and build for the future.

Sounds good but it leaves us with two quota spots and a chunk of cap. No coach is going to allow that situation for long. I'd be surprised if Odgo doesn't have a list of names to fill those places.

I don't see us moving Gale on next season. I'd be happy with the halves going into next season with Trueman swapped for Reynolds.

Hooker is the big one for me, I'd be looking to use Reynolds quota spot on a top NSW or Q Cup hooker. Going into next season I'd like our hookers to be Lovodua, Balmforth and a new overseas recruit.

For me the conundrum is, if we release Manu, what do we do with his overseas spot? Do we sign another backrow, middle or a strike centre?

I can get my head round the Mellor signing if we use him as a squad player, but we'd lose some punch is swapping Manu for him or Lane. But I suppose that's where Griffin to SR comes in.

I think we could get away with replacing Shaul from within. Litten, Barron, Wynne etc.

It might be worth taking a punt on a championship middle like Rovers have done with Garrett/Richards to replace Bowden. Burrell might be seen as a bit green for week in week out games

I'd keep Ma'u if he wants to stay. Been very good this year.

The draw back for me is we kept Mini and Sika probably a season too long. All 3 have been 80 min back rowers for us and the wrong side of 30

A lot of our recruitment and retention is currently based around the potential new deal with SMC, I have heard that a decision could be made in the next few weeks. If we struggle to get a better deal with them then I wouldn't be shocked if we did leave a couple quota spots free for a couple years and go down the younger British route.

I find it hard to justify releasing Houghton and keeping Gale.

I thought AP was trying to reduce costs/debt, not hitting the cap every year?

I took that to mean no Marque players. Times would have to be very hard if we are planning on being under cap. I hope we aren't at that point yet.

I'd look to replace both if we can, but don't see it. Gale was brought in to add leadership and accountability. I just don't see us shipping him out after 1 season.

Some tough decisions coming up, I'm sure last season, we were in a similar league position and in the semi of the cup, we signed up alot of players and our season went slowly down hill. Despite a fee players playing better we need to be ruthless and only keep the players that can help us progress, look at Saints last year, could have kept Coote and Fages, but wanted to put faith in young players and freshen up other areas of the squad.

I'd only look to make minimal changes to the squad, if possible sign Trueman to replace Reynolds, I'm a big fan of Batchelor at Wakefield he'd bring some depth to the back row and we'd have a quota spot to maybe look at bringing a 7 over from overseas.

If Mellor has signed, think we are OK in the backrow.

I expect us to to go with Gale next season at 7, with Hookem and McNamara as backups.

Shauls a tough one, played well on the wing the last few games, would probably have to take a pay cut to stay as not one of our main players anymore.

I think I'd rather have Batchelor than Mellor but haven't seen too much of Mellor this season. I'd agree with Gale, I can see us keeping him for another year, hopefully he'll be on the pitch a bit longer from now.

I'd look to release Johnstone and Bowden definitely, Balmforth and Burrell can take their spots in the squad.

Like you say Shaul us a tough one, depending on the money I'd look to give him another year maybe, especially if Griffin is moving into the back row.

Agree with all that, not sure Mellor is needed, although that might depend on what happens with Ma'u.